Site Overlay

What is a Substitute for Vegetable Shorteners?

Rate this post

Shortening is defined as any fat with a solid texture at room temperature. This category includes lard, butter, margarine, and hydrogenated vegetable oils. In the baking business, lard was the first component employed as a shortening. Margarine, butter, and hydrogenated oils were created and subsequently employed as shortenings.

These chemicals are referred to as shortenings because they cover the gluten strands in flour, preventing them from expanding. As a consequence, the gluten strands are shortening. As a consequence, the finished product is short, crumbly, and crispy yet soft.

Shortenings made from vegetables lack the taste of butter. As a consequence, you won’t obtain the same buttery taste as if you used butter as a shortening.

If you don’t have shortening but still want to make a cake or a pie, some of the replacements in this article may be useful. Substitutes include butter, margarine, lard, coconut oil, palm oil, olive oil, avocado oil, sesame oil, safflower oil, and vegan butter.

Here are Top Substitutes for Vegetable Shorteners

What is a Substitute for Vegetable Shorteners?

1. Butter

Because it offers a buttery taste and a smooth texture to baked items, butter is the most widely used alternative for vegetable shortening. It is manufactured from milk fat and includes very little water but a high concentration of saturated fats.

Because vegetable shortening does not have the same rich taste as butter, using butter in your baking will result in more flavored baked products. Replace butter with the equal quantity of veggie shortening.

2. Lard

If you don’t mind consuming animal products, we can use fat. It may be used in lieu of shortening in many recipes. Lard is a hog fat product that includes a trace of water.

As a consequence, it may be used for deep frying, baking, roasting, sautéing, and grilling. Delicious biscuits, pies, cookies, bread, and savory foods may be made. We may use 1 cup veggie shortening instead of 1 cup lard.

3. Margarine

Margarine is a fat that is created from water and refined vegetable oil and is used in baking, cooking, and seasoning. Because margarine has less fat than vegetable shortening, 1 cup and two tablespoons of margarine must be substituted for 1 cup of vegetable shortening.

Margarine may be used to create cakes, cookies, and bread. It is not, however, advised for frying. If you wish to replace vegetable shortening with margarine, use 80 percent fat margarine. If your baked products are lacking in fat, they will be flat and have a distinct texture.

4. Coconut oil

You may use coconut oil for vegetable shortening if you don’t mind the coconut taste in your dish. This oil has a high fat content and is solid at room temperature.

It may be used in baking, frying, and as a replacement for vegetable shortening in recipes. We may use 1 cup coconut oil for 1 cup vegetable shortening.

5. Olive oil

Because of the taste and texture it lends to meals, olive oil is a popular cooking oil. You may use it in baking if you don’t mind the pungent taste. This oil is high in antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals.

Olive oil has a high concentration of healthy fats that are beneficial to your heart and cholesterol levels. We may use one cup of olive oil for one cup of vegetable shortening.

6. Palm oil

This oil, derived from the fruits of oil palm plants, is also used as a vegetable oil in cooking. It has a savory, earthy taste and a high fat content.

Palm oil is perfect for baking, frying, and sautéing due to its high smoke point. Baked items made with palm oil have a creamy, crunchy texture and an earthy taste. Use a 1:1 substitution for vegetable shortening.

7. Avocado oil

Avocado oil, like olive oil, is abundant in antioxidants and good fats. It is great for frying, baking, sautéing, and roasting because to its high smoke point.

Avocado oil imparts a pleasant, nutty taste and a creamy texture to meals. Avocado oil may be used in lieu of vegetable shortening at a 1:1 ratio.

8. Safflower oil

Safflower oil has a high smoke point and a neutral taste. As a consequence, it is suitable for higher-temperature baking, frying, and cooking. This safflower seed oil provides unsaturated fatty acids that are helpful to heart health. 1 cup vegetable shortening may be replaced with 1 cup safflower oil.

9. Sesame oil

Sesame oil is a light yellow vegetable oil with a nutty taste derived from sesame seeds. It has a very high melting point. As a consequence, it is suitable for frying, baking, and sautéing.

Refined sesame oil has a milder taste than unprocessed sesame oil. If you don’t like strong tastes, substitute refined sesame oil. We may use one cup of sesame oil instead of one cup of vegetable shortening.

10. Vegan butter

Vegetable oils such as olive oil, coconut oil, avocado oil, palm kernel oil, or oils combined with water are used to make vegan butter. For improved taste and texture, this butter additionally includes colorings, flavors, salt, and emulsifiers.

Because of its high fat content, it is a suitable replacement for vegetable shortening. Vegan butter comes in sticks that must be softened before use. Use the same quantity of vegan butter as vegetable shortening in recipes.

11. Applesauce

To boost the density of your baked goods, use applesauce for shortening in sweet baking recipes. One cup of shortening equals half a cup of applesauce.

Recipes you can Make Using Vegetable Shortening

What is a Substitute for Vegetable Shorteners?

1. Vodka Pie Dough

Shortening covers the flour and inhibits the development of gluten, resulting in a flaky crust. The vodka hydrates the dough just enough to hold it together while you roll out the crust, but it rapidly evaporates in the oven, resulting in even more flakiness.

2. Pork Tamales

Lard is the traditional tamale shortening: it makes the tamale dough light and flavorful when whisked into the masa harina.

3. Butter Spritz Cookies

When the dough of our Butter Spritz Cookies is combined, butter prevents gluten from developing, and it is also the predominant taste. Confectioners sugar produces an extraordinarily smooth, silky dough that slides effortlessly through the cookie press.

4. Butter Pie Crust

Instead of water, vinegar hydrates the dough, which, when mixed with the butter, effectively inhibits the creation of gluten, resulting in the most soft, flakiest crust possible.

Basic Nutritional Information for Butter and Shortening

A tablespoon of salted butter has 100 calories, but a tablespoon of shortening contains 115 calories, all of which are from fat. While shortening is devoid of cholesterol, one tablespoon of butter includes 30 milligrams. Although neither is a substantial source of vitamins or minerals, each serving of butter includes 7% of the daily intake for vitamin A as well as trace levels of vitamins E and K, and each serving of shortening provides 7% of the daily value for vitamin K as well as a trace amount of vitamin E.

What is Baking Shortening?

Long gluten strands are avoided from developing while the dough is handled when fat is incorporated into the flour. Consider how gooey and crumbly shortbread biscuits are. They almost melt in your lips and disintegrate if broken with your fingers. They have the polar opposite feel of chewy bread, which has long gluten strands and is known as a long dough.

To make their crusts exceptionally flaky, many pie crusts depend significantly on shortening. The fat in pie crust serves to separate the layers of flour and water. The longer the solid fat keeps the matrix apart, the more air pockets accumulate, causing flakiness. Shortening stays firm for longer than butter because it has a higher melting point.

Can you Substitute Vegetable Oil for Shortening?

We may use vegetable oil instead of shortening. However, the texture will alter if you use them in baking. You may need to add more flour or use less oil since liquid fats react differently with flour than solid fats.

What is the Purpose of Vegetable Shortening in Recipes?

When melted in a pan when frying chicken, vegetable shortening may be used as an oil substitute.

It is used to cover the flour in pie dough, preventing gluten formation and producing the flakiest, delicate dough with small pockets of air that puff when cooked.

Because vegetable shortening has no taste, it will not clash with the other ingredients in the recipe. Most pie crust recipes that employ vegetable shortening, on the other hand, call for butter to enhance taste.

What Role does Lard Play in Recipes?

Lard is utilized in recipes in the same manner as vegetable shortening is: it is used to fry dishes such as chicken, corn chips, and French fries. If given the choice, many individuals would prefer to have their fries and chips cooked in fat.

Because it was solid, lard was the chosen shortening for pie crusts many years ago. Vegetable shortening didn’t exist, and butter was more costly than lard.

What Function does Butter Serve in Recipes?

Butter is not suitable for frying due to its low smoke point and high water content.

However, due to the taste it adds to dishes, it is a fantastic baking shortening. A pie crust made entirely of butter is excellent, but some bakers use equal parts butter and vegetable shortening for the best of both worlds. In cakes and biscuits, creaming butter with sugar gives suppleness and, in certain situations, a delicate crumb: Scottish shortbread is an excellent illustration of how short a cookie may be.

Can Vegetable Oil be Used in Place of Shortening?

In recipes, vegetable oil may be used in place of melted shortening. If you use vegetable oil as a shortening alternative in recipes such as pie crust, biscuits, or scones, the dough will not puff up correctly since there will be no pockets of fat.

What are the Uses of Shortening?

In the kitchen, shortening has a range of culinary uses, some of which are described below.

Because of its high smoke point, shortening is perfect for high-heat cookery, such as deep frying. It is widely used in battered and deep-fried foods to aid with the retention of form and crispiness of the battered food. Remember that the shortening’s composition might alter how much heat your meal can tolerate. Cottonseed oil-based vegetable shortening, for example, has a somewhat lower smoke point than soybean oil-based shortening.

Shortening shortens baking doughs, preventing gluten molecules from forming and resulting in a crumbly, flaky texture. Shortening makes moist cakes, flaky pastry and pie crusts, leavened biscuits, crumbly, chewy scones, and shape-holding cookies.

For frosting, shortening is preferable than butter or oils. To prepare an icing that will not melt all over your baked products if left in warm temps, mix sugar, vanilla, salt, and milk immediately into shortening.

4 Types of Shortening

Shortening is classified into four categories, each with its own set of cooking properties and standards.

Cottonseed and soybean oil are often used in the production of all-purpose shortening, which may or may not include emulsifiers. It is generally used for small-scale commercial or household cooking and baking.

Liquid: Made completely of soybean oil, liquid shortening is often used in recipes that call for melted shortening. Because it does not enable the production of air bubbles, liquid shortening is also appropriate for deep frying but not for pastries.

Solid: When baking, solid shortening retains air bubbles in the dough, preventing the flour from absorbing too much liquid. This yields more leavened dough for breads or puffed pastries and aids in cookie form retention.

This shortening has a greater fat-to-emulsifier ratio, which aids in the retention of moisture in baked products such as cakes. When making frosting, use shortening to protect your icing from melting too soon.Cake


Apart from the above-mentioned popular alternatives, olive oil is regarded to be the greatest choice for replacing an oil. This choice is best suited for savory baked items because to its unique taste. Applesauce is another alternative, although you would use roughly half the quantity compared to the amount of shortening necessary. Related to this post is Substitute Applesauce for Vegetable Oil

If you run out of shortening, don’t panic; certain shortening replacements may influence the taste, rise, or crumb of your baked products. Have fun with your cooking!


What can I use instead of Crisco vegetable shortening?

Best Crisco Alternatives
Any other brand of palm shortening or solid vegetable-based shortening.
Butter that is free of dairy.
Vegetable Oil, Margarine (normal or dairy-free).
The oil of coconut.
Fat from bacon.

What can I substitute 1 cup of shortening with?

Butter. Butter is a natural shortening alternative since it has a comparable texture and a more savory taste. Here’s how to substitute butter for shortening in a recipe that asks for it: 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons butter equals 1 cup shortening.

Is there a substitute for shortening in baking?

Margarine and butter may also be used in place of shortening, but their moisture levels should be considered before making the switch. While shortening is entirely fat, margarine and butter include a tiny amount of water (shortening contributes more fat, and hence greater richness and softness).

Can I substitute butter for shortening?

In a recipe, can I swap butter for shortening or shortening for butter? This is a commonly requested subject, particularly when it comes to baking recipes. Yes, butter and shortening may be used interchangeably in baked items and as a one-to-one substitute.

How much oil do I substitute for shortening?

To use shortening as a replacement for oil in baking, use equal quantities of each. This may be used to replace any sort of cooking oil, including avocado oil, vegetable oil, olive oil, and others.

Can you replace Crisco with butter?

In general, Crisco shortening may be used in place of butter or margarine in equal proportions (1 cup Crisco shortening = 1 cup butter or margarine). Crisco shortening not only has 50% less saturated fat than butter and 0g trans fat per serving, but it also produces higher, lighter-textured baked products.

How much butter do I substitute for shortening?

How to Replace. Use the same quantity of whatever you’re using as directed in the recipe. In other words, the exchange should be one-to-one. If your recipe asks for one cup of butter, use one cup of shortening instead, and vice versa.

What can I substitute for 1 2 cup shortening in baking?

Instead of shortening, use butter or margarine, adding a couple of tablespoons every cup called for in a recipe. Use 1 cup butter or margarine plus 2 tablespoons for every 1 cup of shortening called for in a recipe.

How much butter do I use instead of 1 2 cup shortening?

2 cup shortening (95.5 grams), although you may use butter. Divide the weight of the shortening by 1.25 to get 114.6 grams. This is the amount of butter you’ll need.Using Butter Instead of Shortening

Assume you have a cake recipe that calls for 1 cup of sugar.

When a recipe calls for shortening What is it?

Shortening is defined as any fat that is solid at room temperature. The list isn’t very extensive, and you’re undoubtedly acquainted with the most of them. Lard, margarine, and vegetable shortenings like Crisco are the most well-known and often used in recipes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *