Site Overlay

What Can I Substitute For Tomato Sauce?

Rate this post

If you’re wondering what I can use in place of tomato sauce, here are a few suggestions to help you save money while still eating tasty cuisine. Marinara sauce or fresh tomatoes may also be used. However, you may also use ketchup or tomato paste. One of these choices may be too sweet for your taste. For the greatest results, combine the two! Remember to taste the food first to confirm that the sauce is correct.


Tomato Sauce Nutrition Fact

What Can I Substitute For Tomato Sauce?

What is Tomato Sauce?

What Can I Substitute For Tomato Sauce?

A tomato product has a thicker consistency than tomato juice but not as much as tomato puree. To improve the taste, herbs, spices, onion, and garlic are usually used. Tomato sauce is sold in cans at most grocery shops and is used as a basis for other sauces in a variety of cuisines. Tomato pastes range in texture and taste depth, as do tomato puree and tomato sauce. The thicker the consistency, the richer the taste. Tomato paste has the thickest consistency, puree is thinner than paste, and tomato sauce is the thinnest.

How is Tomato Sauce Made?


  • 4 pound plum tomatoes (or two 28-ounce cans whole peeled plum tomatoes)
  • 6 tablespoons butter, unsalted
  • 4 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
  • 2 peeled and cut in half medium yellow onions
  • 4 garlic cloves, peeled and mashed
  • 114 tablespoons salt
  • 1 tblsp. sugar
  • 2 tablespoons basil leaves, chopped
  1. Make an X on one end of the tomatoes to start. Don’t go any deeper than a quarter-inch.
  2. Cook the tomatoes for 1 to 2 minutes in boiling water, or until the skins peel away. If you simmer the tomatoes for an extended period of time, they will become mushy and difficult to handle.
  3. To halt the cooking process, place the tomatoes in an ice-cold water bath.
  4. Remove the skins from the tomatoes and place them on a cutting board.
  5. Tomatoes should be cut into 1/2-inch chunks.
  6. Combine the diced tomatoes, their seeds and liquids, as well as the butter, olive oil, onions, garlic, salt, and sugar in a large Dutch oven or skillet.
  7. Bring the water to a gentle boil.
  8. 2 to 2 hours, or until the sauce has thickened and no longer seems liquid.Reduce the heat to low and cook for 1 12 hours, uncovered.
  9. Remove the onion and set it aside. Smash any big bits of tomatoes or garlic with a wooden spoon or potato masher to form a somewhat chunky and thick sauce.
  10. Stir in the basil just before serving.
  11. The sauce may be refrigerated for up to 4 days or stored in an airtight container for up to 3 months.

Substitutes for Tomato Sauce

1. Marinara sauce

Canned tomatoes are a great replacement for tomato sauce. Canned tomatoes are normally already smooth, but they may be seasoned with herbs, garlic, and Parmesan cheese to get a similar texture. Alfredo sauce is a great replacement for tomato sauce. Although canned tomatoes may be blended into a silky sauce, they are not the same.

If you don’t have any tomato sauce on hand, you may use ketchup. It has a similar consistency and plenty of tomato flavor but lacks the special seasonings of traditional marinara sauce. Tomato ketchup may be seasoned to complement your dish’s characteristics. To get a genuine marinara flavor, simmer the ketchup for a longer period of time to decrease the liquid and thicken it.

2. Fresh tomatoes

Tomato sauce is a sour, thick soup prepared with chopped or pureed tomatoes, spices, and herbs. This adaptable condiment is often used as a foundation or sauce for a variety of foods. Tomato sauce is an essential component of pasta in Italian cuisine. Fresh tomatoes, on the other hand, may be substituted for canned tomatoes. In a recipe, you may also use fresh tomato paste for tomato sauce.

Instead of producing your own sauce, consider substituting 1 cup tomato soup for 1 cup tomato sauce. This alternative has the same consistency and taste of tomato sauce but does not have the delicious flavour of marinara. This substitute may also be seasoned with minced garlic and extra salt. Using tomato paste will also result in a more authentic Italian tomato flavor. When the tomato paste is done, add it to the sauce and mix thoroughly.

3. Tomato paste

Tomato paste is a more concentrated and thicker version of tomato sauce. Tomato paste, which is formed from pureed or chopped tomatoes that have been purged of their skins and seeds, has a somewhat different taste and consistency than tomato sauce. Tomato paste is often used in place of tomato sauce in cooking, and it may thicken stews, soups, and other recipes that call for sauce.

In other circumstances, you may choose to avoid using tomato paste entirely. There are, however, different methods to replace tomato sauce. Miso, a traditional Japanese condiment, may be added to any dish to give it a deeper taste and color. Miso paste is a common ingredient in Italian cookery, and store-bought versions may be found in most grocery shops. It has a taste profile comparable to tomato sauce but is sweeter and less salty.

4. Ketchup

In any recipe that calls for catsup, use tomato sauce instead of ketchup. A excellent alternative will have the distinct taste of ketchup without the need for cooking or pre-heating. It may be manufactured using tomato paste or by purifying a jar of premade tomato sauce. A good homemade ketchup will be more flavorful and complex. It may also be used as a marinade or a barbecue sauce.

Among the various ketchup replacements, basic American mustard is the healthiest. This plant-based condiment helps with metabolism, cancer prevention, and bone strength. For a boost of heat, use Sriracha or other spicy sauces. Depending on your preferences, tomato sauce is typically blander than ketchup, and the option is totally yours.

5. Beets and Carrots

Beets and carrots as a tomato sauce substitute are a tasty and nutritious alternative to the classic sauce. Beets offer natural sweetness and taste, as well as being abundant in nutrients; they help reduce blood pressure and are heart-healthy owing to their high nitrate level. Our recipes are all oil-free and vegan. This pasta sauce is ideal for individuals who do not want to forego the flavor and color of their favorite pasta meal.

Because of their deep earthy aromas, beets and carrots are great substitutes for red tomato sauce. To make a rich sauce, roast them and purée them in a blender. Pureed beets and carrots may also be used in spaghetti sauce, where they will boil down to a thick sauce. You may also add a splash of olive oil to your mixture to obtain a smooth consistency and lend a flavor boost.

6. Tomato Juice

To replace tomato sauce with tomato juice, just use the same quantity of pureed tomatoes. You may use the whole can of tomatoes or only the juice. Alternatively, tomato soup, which has a similar taste to tomato juice, may be used. In any case, just a little quantity of tomato juice should be used for the remainder of the dish. Tomato sauce is commonly accessible and may be used in a variety of cuisines.

You may manufacture your own tomato juice by combining tomato pulp and water. Add salt and sugar to get the desired liquid consistency and flavor. You should experiment with various ratios to find the optimal substitute. Fresh tomatoes may also be used, but they must be washed, peeled, and blended. Remove the seeds from fresh tomatoes and use the liquid in the recipe.

Some Tomato Sauce Recipes

My Chili

This chili has a thick and robust taste thanks to the tomato sauce, ground beef, and kidney beans. To counteract the fiery chili powder, top with a dollop of sour cream or a sprinkle of cheese.

Basil Tomato Soup

This soup is velvety smooth and soothing, with herbs like oregano and basil adding fresh taste. To empty out the dish, serve with a piece of garlic bread and top with croutons.

Tomato Sauce Poached Eggs

For a stunning breakfast, serve this poached egg dish instead of scrambled eggs or an omelet. Cook them in a delicious tomato sauce seasoned with parsley, oregano, and red pepper flakes.


Fideo, a thin Mexican noodle comparable to angel hair pasta, is the centerpiece of this meal. It’s cooked in a tomato broth with cumin, garlic, and chili powder. Top with shredded cheese, as reviewer Rosemary did, for an extra indulgent meal.

Why would you Use a Substitute?

There are various reasons why you should avoid typical tomato sauce. For one thing, you may not have it on hand. Even if you have canned or bottled tomato sauce on hand, you will eventually run out. Instead of canceling your dinner plans and ordering takeout or making a last-minute trip to the grocery store, consider one of the alternatives listed below.

There are also some health reasons to avoid tomato sauce. Anyone who has a tomato allergy, for example, should avoid eating tomato sauce. Tomatoes may induce gout, according to anecdotal evidence, although studies have yet to substantiate this.Tomatoes are a member of the nightshade family of foods and spices, and they contain chemical compounds known as alkaloids. Alkaloids are toxic in high levels, although the quantity in tomatoes is negligible.

Tomato Paste: Homemade vs. Store-Bought

It takes some time to make your own tomato paste, but it is well worth the effort, particularly if you can acquire farm-fresh tomatoes at the farmers market. Because the tastes become more concentrated while the pasta boils, the ability to pick the tomatoes has a considerable influence on the flavor profile of the tomato paste.

For the greatest results, use meaty tomatoes such as Roma or San Marzano. Because heirloom tomatoes contain more water, they produce less finished product while producing a more flavorful paste.

What Quantity of Ketchup to Use for Tomato Sauce?

Yes, ketchup may be used in place of tomato paste. Because ketchup is already rather concentrated, a 1:1 replacement from the bottle (if your recipe asks for one tablespoon of tomato paste, use one tablespoon of ketchup) is possible. Keep in mind that most ketchup includes a lot of sugar, so the finished dish may be a bit sweeter than you planned. Because ketchup is considerably sweeter than tomato paste, if your recipe asks for more than a tablespoon or two, it’s usually not the greatest option.

Is it Possible to Leave Seeds in Tomato Sauce?

Because the inner pulp and gel surrounding the seeds hold a majority of the tomato taste, the seeds should be left in when cooking. For the finest taste, use whole, unpeeled tomatoes, and mix once cooked for a smooth consistency.

Can I Make Pizza with Pasta Sauce Instead of Tomato Sauce?

Yes, with a few tweaks, pasta sauce may be used in place of pizza sauce. Reduce the remaining water (you may drain it) and simmer it longer for a richer sauce. To smooth out huge pieces in your spaghetti sauce, mix or pulse it in a food processor.


With the list above, you may discover an outstanding tomato sauce alternative for every scenario or dish. Try one of these choices next time you make a basic pasta meal or something more complicated.

When utilizing these substitutions, keep consistency in mind. Because ketchup, tomato puree or juice, and fresh tomatoes contain more liquid than tomato paste, the liquid should be decreased in recipes that ask for a thicker concentration.

The following alternatives are easy to make, yet they provide the same taste and texture to cuisine. So, if you’re out of tomato sauce, make or buy one of these substitutes, include it into your dishes, and enjoy it with your family.


What is the substitute of 1 cup tomato sauce?

Can of tomato soup, 4 oz.Ketchup and tomato soup are two more tomato sauce substitutes.

1 cup ketchup may be substituted for 1 cup tomato sauce. As required, add spices to adjust the taste. A little basil is an excellent addition. To make tomato soup, add a 10 3

Can I use ketchup instead of tomato sauce?

Because ketchup is created from tomatoes, it may easily be used as a tomato sauce alternative in a number of dishes—just use your discretion and taste as you go to adjust the flavour. Ketchup works best as a replacement in recipes that already have some sweetness.

Can you substitute crushed tomatoes for tomato sauce?

-Mix one can of crushed tomatoes. Then, in your recipe, substitute it for the tomato sauce. Crushed tomatoes are somewhat thicker than tomato sauce, but they will still work nicely.

What can I substitute for tomato sauce if I m allergic to tomatoes?

If tomato isn’t a key flavor in your recipe or you’re sensitive to it, roasted red peppers are a great substitute. Open a container or roast your own and blend in a food processor. They will provide a splash of color and taste but will lack the thickness of tomato paste.

What is the same as tomato sauce?

Tomato sauce

Tomato paste is an excellent alternative for tomato sauce since it is, well, tomato sauce—albeit in a highly concentrated form.

What is a substitution for 8 ounces of tomato sauce?

To make 8 ounces of tomato sauce, use 2 cup of water as indicated above.2 cup tomato paste plus 1Because an 8-ounce can of tomato sauce equals 1 cup, you may combine 1

Does ketchup taste different to tomato sauce?

Ketchup and tomato sauce are two condiments that are often used interchangeably, however they vary in terms of ingredients and use. Sauce is a savory condiment prepared from tomatoes, onions, garlic, and other vegetables and herbs, while ketchup is a sweet and tangy condiment.

What is the basic difference between tomato sauce and ketchup?

Spices and acetic acid. It’s a dressing or a table condiment. Ketchup is served cold and is never cooked. Tomato sauce, on the other hand, is a combination of tomatoes, oil, meat or vegetable stock, and spices.Ketchup is made in the United States from tomatoes, sugar, and vinegar.

Can I use salsa instead of tomato sauce?

The thinner consistency is an excellent substitute for marinara sauce. And, as salsa is made mostly of summer ingredients, it makes perfect sense to pair it with this Summer Salad Pasta, don’t you think? The majority of pasta meals that revolve on a tomato-based sauce are marinara.

Can I use marinara instead of tomato sauce?

In most cases, marinara sauce and tomato sauce may be used interchangeably. Tomato sauce, on the other hand, will be lighter and thinner than thicker and more complicated marinara sauce. Tomato sauce may be too thick for a pizza, but marinara may be too thin for meals like eggplant and chicken parmesan.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *