Site Overlay

Use Sourdough Starter Instead of Yeast in Baking Recipes

Rate this post

whether you’re wondering whether you can use sourdough starter instead of yeast in baking recipes, you’ve come to the correct spot. Here you’ll discover information on how to replace yeast with sourdough starter, how to utilize a sourdough starter, and the flavor changes you’ll notice. Using a sourdough starter, it is simple to adapt sourdough bread recipes.

Have you ever wished to use sourdough starter in a yeast recipe or experiment with different flavors while baking? This article addresses using sourdough starter in recipes instead of dried yeast. While you’ll need to be creative with the ingredients and rising time, the primary idea is to determine how much flour and water to leave out when adding the starter.

While this looks to be a straightforward process, there are a few things to consider that may seem obvious to some but are worth discussing just in case.

What is Sourdough Starter and How to Make it?

Substitute Sourdough Starter For Yeast in Your Baking Recipes

It’s no surprise that sourdough starter has gained popularity in recent months. Slower, more attentive cooking is growing popular among home chefs and bakers, and what better place to begin than with the most fundamental of foods: bread? Humans have been spontaneously leavening their bread for tens of thousands of years using just three basic ingredients: flour, water, and time. You now have a delicious and healthy loaf of bread with the addition of salt.

Baking sourdough bread enables you to combine science and creativity in order to make something tasty, healthful, and visually appealing with your hands. This may look hard, but believe me, it is not. Because sourdough has gained popularity in the food media and on social media, there is an abundance of information accessible. I’ve spent many hours reading cookbooks, other blogs, online baking resources and forums, and, most importantly, social media discussions with other sourdough bakers. Because the starter has received the most inquiries, I’ve put together this resource for you to use as you begin your sourdough adventure.

What Exactly is Yeast?

Substitute Sourdough Starter For Yeast in Your Baking Recipes

The scientific term for yeast used in the food and beverage industries is Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Yeast is often advertised as fast yeast or active dry yeast on grocery store shelves. When dry yeast is mixed with water, it transforms into a live, breathing organism and a single-celled fungus that starts to respond. The sugar in the components (such bread flour) is consumed by yeast, which creates carbon dioxide bubbles.

Yeast also aids in the rising process and the production of gluten in the dough.

Because yeast is necessary for leavening to occur, this is a simple explanation. In a pinch, though, there are good yeast substitutes.

Why Convert a Sourdough Recipe?

You may be asking why someone would want to modify a sourdough recipe in the first place. After all, sourdough is more difficult to create than fast yeast. Here are a few benefits and reasons to try preparing your favorite dish using Sourdough.

Sourdough Aids in the Digestibility and Nutritiousness of Recipes

Some of us cannot digest gluten unless it is in a sourdough form, while others just choose to consume wheat in a sourdough form since it is simpler to digest and more nutritious than the yeast version. In my article Is Sourdough Bread Healthy? Learn more about the health benefits of oSourdoughgh.

When you us Sourdoughgh in a recipe, you get more complex flavours

Making a sourdough version of your favorite yeast dishes will add a whole new layer of flavor and complexity to them, converting them from ordinary to spectacular.

Making the switch to sourdough adds a fun challenge to your baking!

When I want to test my bread-baking abilities, I like to see if I can convert a tried-and-true recipe into a sourdough one! When done correctly, this will offer a tried-and-true dish a whole new flavor and texture, making it a very pleasant experience!

Is it Possible to Convert Other Non-Yeast Recipes?

So far, we’ve covered the fundamentals of changing a yeast recipe to a sourdough recipe, but other recipes can be changed as well. Some instances of bread that may be transformed are as follows:

Breadsticks (Pancakes, Waffles, Crepes, etc.)

These are usually transformed into sourdough variants, which add a lot of flavor and fluffiness to the finished dish. These recipes, on the other hand, do not use yeast and instead depend on baking soda or baking powder to rise.

How to Turn a Quickbread Recipe into a Cake?

There are three easy stages to each quickbread recipe:

Simply substitute sourdough starter for portion of the wheat and water.

or, as a last step, baking soda.Before baking, add the baking powder and

Fermentation should take at least 4 hours. (If you’re only adding a beginning to your meal for flavor rather than additional benefits, skip this step.)

during you add the baking powder or baking soda at the end, your quickbreads will rise the most during heating or baking. You will observe the mixture rising as you pour it in!

How to Create a Sourdough Starter from Scratch?

It takes at least 5 days to cultivate a sourdough starter, but once you have one, it is easy to maintain and utilize. You will need the following:

2 cups all-purpose flour (600 g)minimum 2 1

2 1/2 cups (600 mL) water minimum

Follow these instructions to make your own sourdough starter:

2 cup (120 mL) water and wrap in plastic wrap or a clean kitchen towel loosely. Allow to cool till room temperature.2 cups (120 grams) flourDay 1: Combine 1 in a large glass jar.

Fill a mixing basin with 2 cup (120 mL) water and feed the starting. Allow it cool to room temperature before lightly wrapping. At the end of day 2, bubbles should appear, showing that the yeast is growing and fermenting the flour.Day 2: Combine 2 cups (120 grams) flour and 1

Day 3: Reverse the previous day’s steps. The mixture should smell yeasty and contain a lot of bubbles.

Day 4: Reverse the previous day’s steps. There should be more bubbles, a more pungent and sour fragrance, and the size should increase.

Day 5: Retrace your steps from the previous day. Your sourdough starter should be bubbling and yeasty smelling. It is presently operational.

2 cup water (120 mL).2 cups (120 grams) flourAfter the fifth day, store your sourdough starter in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Use or discard half of it every week, and feed it with 1

Any sourdough starter that has been infected with fuzzy, white, or colored mold should be discarded.

Because bread takes at least 5 days to generate a sourdough starter, this yeast alternative is preferable if you already have one or can wait 5 days before baking.

Is it Possible to Make Sourdough Cakes?

Because of the sugar content in cakes, the sourdough starter does not do a good job of fermenting the flour in the batter. However, it is a fantastic way to add new flavors to your cakes and a great way to use up any extra sourdough!

Simply whisk in a tiny bit of sourdough starter to observe how it impacts the flavor. As previously stated, the combination will not ferment in the typical manner.Sourdough, but the flavor will change.

What are the Important Things to Consider When Making Sourdough Recipes?

There are a few factors to bear in mind while modifying recipes to tSourdoughgh:

Sugar content of the recipe

When a dish has an excessive amount of sugarSourdough just does not work as well in fermentation. In a sourdough bake, no more than 10% sugar should be used; more than 10% will inhibit natural bacteria and yeast from fermenting the wheat, forcing it to ferment too rapidly and damaging the texture and structure of the meal.

So, if the dish you want to convert has more than 10% sugar, such cakes, you may add sourdough starter to the mix for flavor rather than the slow fermentation advantages. It’s an excellent way to use up any sourdough starter or leftovers. It cannot, however, be converted into a traditional fermented recipe.

Never De-Gas Sourdough or Knock Back!

Many yeast-based bread recipes instruct you to knock back or de-gas the dough. This should never be done with risen dough that has been gently fermented. Sourdough should be handled with caution and should not be hammered back or de-gassed in any way. It has spent hours developing and expanding, and knocking it back will ruin everything! You may skip this step completely if you’re converting a bread recipe that calls for it.

Sourdough has its Own Personality!

These basic criteria have always worked well for me, but it is essential to remember that everyone’s experience with sourdough is unique. Learn your craft and be prepared to trust your instincts if a recipe asks for a bit more flour or a little less time to ferment than the recipe calls for. It may take many tries to convert a recipe before you get it perfect, but once you do, you won’t be sorry!

In Comparison to My Yeast Recipe, How Long Should I Let it Rise?

Allow your sourdough recipe to rise for at least twice as long as the yeast recipe specifies, including the bulk ferment (first rise) and the second rise (after shaping).

Your sourdough bread should rise for at least 4 hours, with a 2-hour second rise, after a 1-hour proving phase and a 1-hour second rise.If your bread recipe specifies a 2-hour rising time,

Sourdough, variations in rising times will be more significant

The length of time you leave the bread to rise is, of course, regulated by the temperature of the surroundings, and this applies to both yeast and sourdough bread. Keep in mind that the sourdough version of any recipe will have more variation simply because it must rise for a longer amount of time. For more information on rising periods dependent on temperature, see my post Best Temperature to Proof Sourdough: Full Guide & How To.

proofing period without having to be concerned about the temperature of your bread’s surroundings (Amazon link).A yeast recipe’s rise time, for example, may vary by a half-hour here and there, but a sourdough recipe’s rise time may vary by a couple of hours. This bread proofing station is a wonderful way to reduce rising guessing.

Adjustments to the flour and water When Making Sourdough from a Recipe

Not with fresh yeast.When converting recipes, bear in mind the additional components from your sourdough starter. Because sourdough starter is mostly wheat and water, it gives texture and consistency that dry yeast does not.

The recipe alteration will be determined by the moisture level of your beginning. If you feed your sourdough starting the same amount of flour as water, you’ll need to decrease that amount of liquid and flour from your original recipe to account for the surplus from your starter.

If your sourdough starter is not given the same quantity of water as flour, adjust the recipe. The quantity of starting you use (e.g., 100 grams) will stay constant, but your recipe will be changed according on how much flour and water your starter contains.


Yeast adds airiness, lightness, and chewiness to baked goods, although replacement ingredients may be used in a hurry.

Baking powder, like baking soda coupled with an acid, interacts with liquid and heat to form bubbles and leaven baked products. There is no need for a rise time since these yeast replacements respond quickly. They may not, however, create the same evident rising movement as yeast.

A sourdough starter may also be used, with comparable results as yeast. A sourdough starter, on the other hand, takes nearly twice the rise time, and the liquid and flour ratios must be changed based on the thickness of your starter.




Can I use sourdough starter instead of yeast?

Can sourdough starter be used instead of fresh yeast? Yes, you may use sourdough starter instead of fresh yeast; however, you must adjust the quantity of flour and water in the bread recipe to account for the sourdough starter’s flour and water.

What does sourdough starter do to baked goods?

A sourdough starter is a leavening agent made of fermented flour and water that employs naturally occurring yeasts and bacteria to raise baked products.

How much sourdough starter to use?

See “tips” for further information. Remove as much starter as you need for your recipe – no more than 227 grams, or roughly 1 cup. If your recipe asks for more than 1 cup of starter, feed it many times without discarding until you have enough for your recipe plus 113 grams to save and feed again.

Is sourdough starter healthier than yeast?

To leaven the dough, sourdough uses a combination of wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria rather than baker’s yeast. It’s higher in nutrients, less prone to cause blood sugar spikes, has less gluten, and is typically simpler to digest than bread produced with baker’s yeast.

Can you use too much sourdough starter?

Yes, your sourdough starter may be overfed. According to Audrey, “every time you add more flour and water, you are depleting the existing population of natural bacteria and yeast.” If you keep adding more and more, the starter will get so diluted that you will just have flour and water.

Can I use any flour with my sourdough starter?

Strong bread flour is an excellent choice for producing sourdough starter, although it is not always accessible. In this scenario, plain white all-purpose flour may provide excellent results. You may also use a combination of spelt, whole wheat, or rye flour(s) with all-purpose or bread flour.

When should you not use sourdough starter?

Using a sourdough starter immediately after feeding is not recommended. You should ideally wait at least 2-4 hours. When you initially feed a sourdough starter, it is at its most vulnerable. It hasn’t had enough time to digest the sugars in the flour, so it’s flat and inert.

Can I put my sourdough starter in the oven?

Yes, you may use sourdough starter directly from the fridge to bake with.

When can I bake with my sourdough starter?

When your starting consistently doubles in size within 8 hours of being fed, it’s ready to bake with — or save for later. If you want to store your fed starter in the fridge, let it to rest at room temperature for 2 hours after feeding.

How much do I feed 2 cups of sourdough starter?

2 cup (113g) starter, as normal, with equal parts flour and water (113g each).If your recipe asks for 2 cups (454g) starter, add 227g flour and 227g water. When the starter is “ripe” (ready to use), spoon out what you need for the recipe and store it with the other ingredients. Feed the last one

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *