Site Overlay

Substitute for Roma Tomatoes

Rate this post

When it comes to creating tomato paste, many chefs use Roma tomatoes. When compared to conventional tomatoes, it contains more meat and less water content, allowing it to make thick bodied sauces.

There are several types of tomatoes, and they all have a similar tart taste but vary in texture. For example, the texture of Roma tomatoes makes them perfect for canned tomato sauces often seen in supermarkets. So, if you ever find yourself in a scenario where you need to replace this item, there are a variety of alternatives available in shops that may be utilized in its stead. So, in this essay, we’ll look at a few of them.

What is a Roma Tomato?

Substitute for Roma Tomatoes

Roma tomatoes are plum tomatoes with smooth red meaty flesh, fewer seeds, and less moisture than other varieties of tomatoes. It has an elongated form, almost like an egg, and is suitable for manufacturing canned tomato paste or sauce variants. Roma tomatoes come in a variety of hues, the most popular being red, but they also come in yellow and orange, which have a milder taste. The baby Roma tomato is a smaller variation of the Roma tomato.

The Roma tomato originates in South America and is popular in Mexico; it is a 1955 hybrid of the Pan American tomato and the San Marzano tomato. It grows in the United States, Australia, Mexico, and the United Kingdom.

Roma tomatoes are high in vitamins A, B, and C, as well as iron, fiber, and potassium. It is also beneficial to the heart and aids in the reduction of cholesterol. Lycopene, which is present in most tomatoes, is responsible for the color and antioxidant production in Roma tomatoes. Lycopene also possesses anti-cancer properties, which aid in the prevention and healing of damaged cells in the body.

Roma tomato used in Recipes

Substitute for Roma Tomatoes

Roma tomato can be prepared using different methods since it is less juicy and has more flesh. It may be eaten raw or cooked, and is often used to produce sauces and paste, slow-roasted recipes, stuffings and baked products, chopped salads, and many other dishes. These tomatoes may also be dried and used to foods; they contribute both sweet and savory tastes to recipes, which include the following:

  • Creamy Tomato Basil Chicken
  • Slow-Roasted Tomatoes
  • Creamy Cucumber Tomato Salad
  • Basil Tomato Puree
  • Peach Salsa
  • Easy Marinated Tomatoes
  • Homemade Pico de Gallo
  • Herb-Crusted Baked Tomatoes
  • Bruschetta Chicken Bake
  • Baked Caprese Chicken
  • Balsamic-Glazed Caprese
  • Roasted Tomato Basil Soup
  • Homemade Tomato Paste
  • Lemon Basil Chicken Pasta
  • Cucumber Tomato Avocado Salad

Roma Tomato Substitute

Roma tomatoes are high in nutrients and are used in a variety of dishes; they are widely accessible in grocery stores in canned pastes and sauces, but they may also be made and preserved at home. If you run out of this item or can’t locate it, other options may be used to replace it in recipes. Among them are the following:

1. San Marzano

San Marzano tomatoes are sometimes classified as plum tomatoes. The San Marzano tomato is slimmer and more pointed than the Roma, but it is also fleshier and contains less seeds, similar to a plum tomato.

Because of the comparable characteristics, San Marzano is a wonderful alternative for Roma tomato and may be used in sauces, pasta, vegetable dishes, and so on. The San Marzano tomato is widely available in supermarkets. When replacing, the same amount used in recipes for Roma tomatoes may be used for San Marzano tomatoes.

2. Amish Tomato

The Amish tomato is a variant of the plum tomato that is said to have evolved in the 1870s in a historic Amish village in Wisconsin, Medford. Although it is often created as a paste, the sweet raw form may be utilized in both raw and cooked dishes.

The Amish tomato is a fragile perennial with an indeterminate growth pattern that grows well in warm regions. This tomato has a taste comparable to San Marzano and would work well in Roma tomato dishes. In any recipe, the same amount used for Roma tomatoes may be used for Amish tomatoes.

3. Roco

Another form of plum tomato is the ropreco tomato, which is fleshy and used to make canned tomato paste. It grows in California, Minnesota, and Palo Alto. It has a determinate growth habit, is open-pollinated, and disease resistant.

Many culinary lovers consider the ropreco tomato to be even sweeter than the Roma tomato. It complements both fresh and cooked meals such as salsas, salads, soups, sauces, sandwiches, roasted foods, and so on. When replacing ropreco for Roma tomato, use a 1:1 ratio.

4. Big Mama

Big Mama is a plum tomato that may be substituted for Roma in rich and creamy recipes. Canned and raw varieties are available in supermarkets, while fresh versions may be utilized in both raw and cooked dishes.

When cooked, the big mama’s skin peels easily and makes wonderful thick sauces. When replacing big mama for the Roma tomato, use less large mama, but use the precise proportions if you don’t mind the thick and creamy paste.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much tomato fruit is produced by a single Roma plant?

A single Roma plant may yield up to 200 fruits.

What is the difference between a Roma tomato and a regular tomato?

Roma tomatoes are less juicy and seedy than regular tomatoes. They have a smaller seed and are used often in the preparation of homemade and canned tomato paste.

Which is the best type of plum tomato to use?

Many culinary experts considered the San Marzano plum tomato to be the greatest sort of plum tomato. This Italian tomato is cultivated in the lush soil of Campania and produces some of the greatest canned pastes.


The Roma tomato is a plum tomato that is used in sauces and other dishes. If you can’t obtain this specific tomato, another plum tomato type may be substituted.


Can you use regular tomatoes instead of Roma?

Roma tomatoes are meaty, seedless, oval-shaped tomatoes. Regular tomatoes, on the other hand, are bigger spherical tomatoes with a somewhat greater water content. While they may be swapped for each other in recipes, the effectiveness of the replacement will depend on what you’re creating.

Can I use canned tomatoes instead of Roma tomatoes?

Recipes Using Tomatoes

In your recipe, you may use almost any sort of tomato you like. Consider plum or Roma tomatoes if you want to replicate the taste of canned tomatoes. If you’re preparing a sauce, beefsteak and San Marzano tomatoes are also terrific options.

Can you substitute cherry tomatoes for Roma tomatoes?

Can you use cherry tomatoes for Roma tomatoes? In general, several types of tomatoes may be substituted in a pinch. However, the effectiveness of the substitute will be determined on your recipe. As previously said, Roma tomatoes are meatier, but cherry tomatoes are sweeter and have a greater water content.

What is the difference between cherry tomatoes and Roma tomatoes?

Roma tomatoes are bigger than cherry and grape tomatoes, but not big enough to slice. Roma tomatoes are frequently referred to as plum tomatoes. A 62-gram Roma tomato has 11 calories and 1 gram of fiber (2). Because they are naturally sweet and juicy, they are an excellent option for preserving or creating sauces.

What tomato is most similar to Roma tomatoes?

The Amish paste tomato is a popular heritage variety among seed savers. It looks like a Roma tomato, but it has a fresher sweet-meets-tangy taste. Because Amish paste tomatoes are plum-shaped and may swell up to 8 to 12 ounces, they work best when staked.

What can I use instead of Roma tomatoes for salsa?

Tomatoes with beefsteak flavor

They have a somewhat higher acidity than Roma tomatoes, but their sweetness may assist to compensate. Beefsteak tomatoes are versatile and may be used in a number of dishes, including salsa. Because they are huge and juicy, they are simple to cut into little pieces.

What makes Roma tomatoes different?

Roma is a variety of tomato varietals that are popular for sauces and preserving. They contain less moisture than other, juicier tomato types like beefsteak tomatoes. Romas have a thick fruit wall and skin, firm and dense flesh, and they have fewer seeds.

Are Italian tomatoes the same as Roma tomatoes?

Because of its slim and solid character, the Roma tomato or Roma is a plum tomato that is popular for preserving and preparing tomato paste. Roma tomatoes, which are often accessible in stores in several countries, are also known as Italian tomatoes or Italian plum tomatoes.

Why use Roma tomatoes?

Roma tomatoes were selected for their form, disease resistance, and longevity. Because of these characteristics, the Roma tomato has been extensively adapted across the United States, and it is resistant to illnesses prevalent in chilly, rainy climes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *