Site Overlay

Substitute for Porcini Mushrooms

5/5 - (1 vote)

To maintain a healthy diet, you need to choose the right components so that you can get the most out of them. In this context, porcini mushrooms stand out as one of the most suitable food choices. They’re distinctive, adaptable, and enhance any dish. In addition to this, they provide a substantial quantity of several important minerals to the diet.

On the other hand, porcini mushrooms are not always available, which is why it is necessary to choose a suitable alternative. In this section, we will examine the many different kinds of food that might serve as suitable replacements for porcini mushrooms. But before we go on to it, let’s have a more in-depth conversation about this fascinating fungus. And while we’re at it, let’s investigate the many of ways that it might be employed in the delicious foods that surround us.

What are Porcini Mushrooms?

Porcini mushrooms, also known as penny bun mushrooms, are a kind of wild fungus that may be found mostly in parts of Italy. They are known by their scientific name, Boletus epulis, and have white stems. Their black crowns may grow to be up to 10 inches in diameter when they reach their full size. Fall and winter are the typical growing seasons for porcini mushrooms, which is also the time of year when they are harvested and eaten. Although the mushrooms may be consumed fresh, the majority of people choose to dry them first, and it is in this condition that they are distributed to more remote areas of the nation. It is also possible to grind it up into a powder and package it in jars to sell as a spice or seasoning.

Porcini Mushrooms in Recipes

The inclusion of fresh porcini mushrooms, which have a flavor profile that is described as neutral but earthy, makes it possible to easily integrate the recipe’s flavor profile. However, the majority of people choose adding the dried versions instead since they possess a taste that is more soft, creamy, and nutty. The flavor and scent of the mushrooms are both high in the umami component. In addition to this, they are denser and have a sweeter flavor compared to some of the edible alternatives. In addition to that, they are loaded with vitamins A and C, as well as other antioxidants, fiber, and iron.

The paleo diet and vegan diet both often include porcini mushrooms in their meal plans. As a single side dish, they may be fried, sautéed, grilled, boiled, or steamed according on the preparation method chosen. However, the mushrooms are also often used in meals that are either raw or cooked in a variety of European cuisines. Both the fresh and dried forms may be used, however the dried form must first be rehydrated by soaking it in warm water for a few minutes before it can be worked with. In addition, part of its earthy, savory, and umami aroma and taste are transferred to the liquid, which may subsequently be used into other dishes.

Numerous meat, fish, seafood, and vegetable meals all include porcini mushrooms in one form or another. The following are examples of some of these recipes:

  • Soups
  • Sauces
  • Tagliatelle
  • Porcini mushroom cream
  • Risotto
  • Cannelloni
  • Truffle oil pasta with mushrooms
  • Porcini mushroom tortelloni
  • Fettuccine
  • Stews
  • Ravioli
  • Gravy
  • Salads
  • Mashed potatoes
  • Pork chops
  • Porcini mushroom pate
  • Halibut
  • Creamy porcini mushrooms
  • Cicchetti
  • Roasted turkey breast
  • Pork medallions
  • Porcini crusted cod
  • Porcini mushroom sauté
  • Fried porcini mushrooms
  • Pork tenderloin
  • Frittata
  • Seafood dishes
  • Seasoning salt
  • Chicken with porcini mushrooms
  • Popcorn
  • Mushroom ketchup
  • Bucatini with porcini mushroom ragu
  • Pappardelle with mushrooms
  • Grilled porcini mushrooms
  • Creamy Orzo with porcini
  • Italian sausage and porcini mushroom
  • Stroganoff
  • Porcini mac and cheese

Porcini Mushroom Substitutes

There is a rather small window of opportunity to harvest porcini mushrooms, namely August through October. In addition, during this time period, there is a plethora of mushrooms to be found growing in the damp woods of Italy and many other countries of Europe. However, after the growing season is through, you will only be able to find the dried versions. And some types may be rather pricey, particularly considering the fact that they have a more robust taste and scent.

However, if you want to prepare mushroom soup that is smooth and creamy, you won’t have to break your savings account every time. Your recipes may still have a fair amount of nuttiness, umami, and creaminess even if you use one of these other ingredients instead of the original.

Shiitake Mushrooms

The shiitake mushroom is the finest option for you to use in place of the porcini. And the most of the time, you won’t even be able to detect the difference when it’s being utilized. Both varieties of mushroom have very similar taste patterns, with the exception that shiitake mushrooms do not have an earthy undertone. However, the taste is far more robust when compared to that of porcini mushrooms, and since it lacks the earthiness of porcini mushrooms, it may be used in a wider variety of cuisines. Additionally, shiitake is more cost-effective and may be found at any supermarket. In addition, preparing it for use in cooking is not nearly as difficult as preparing porcini mushrooms, and it may be replaced for them in equal amounts.

Portobello Mushrooms

The Portobello mushroom is yet another useful substitute for button mushrooms. Its taste profile is virtually as earthy as porcini mushroom’s, however it has a stronger scent than porcini mushroom does. Because they are meatier, Portobello mushrooms are a good choice for recipes that call for them to be sautéed, stir-fried, or grilled. In addition, they are fantastic for producing creamy mushroom sauce because the robust umami taste of the mushrooms comes through just as strongly as it does with porcini. Any recipe that calls for porcini mushrooms may have the same number of Portobello mushrooms substituted in its place.

Truffle Oil

This tasty alternative may also be used in its place of porcini mushrooms in any recipe that calls for them. Gourmet restaurants have been using truffle oil for decades to provide a rich taste and fragrant character to the cuisine they prepare for their customers. In order to extract the taste from the truffles into the oil, either fresh or dried truffles are soaked in oil for a period of time. The end product has a taste and aroma reminiscent to mushrooms and also contains a significant amount of the nutrients that are found in truffles. In addition, truffle oil is rich in calories, despite the fact that it has a flavor profile that is very similar to that of porcini mushrooms. If this is not going to be a problem for you, then you may use it as a replacement in the majority of the meals.


It’s reassuring to know that zucchinis aren’t simply one of our favorite nutrient-dense vegetable foods that are often found across the world. They are also an excellent substitute for porcini mushrooms, particularly the dried versions of those mushrooms. The zucchini has a subtle taste and adds an additional juiciness that goes well with raw meals, hot salads, and dishes that are just partially cooked. In addition to having less calories than other options, it imparts dishes with a fragrance and taste that is somewhat sweet and earthy. When substituting zucchini for porcini mushrooms, there is a possibility that the dish may take on a fruitier flavor. Despite this, the taste characteristics of both components are so identical that you won’t even perceive the difference.

Tomato Paste

Tomato paste may, surprisingly, stand in for porcini mushrooms if you’re in a need and need a quick answer. This comes in very handy when you’re out of porcini mushrooms. Tomato paste is a good substitute for porcini mushrooms in situations where a robust umami taste is desired since it has a high concentration of nutrient-dense ingredients and is easy to get. If you are trying to lose weight, you should be aware that it is an element that contains a lot of calories. In addition, tomato paste adds a touch of sweetness to dishes, and it goes particularly well with stews, pasta, meats, and fish.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I substitute dried shiitake mushrooms for dried porcini?

Yes, you can. Both fresh and dried versions of the mushrooms have an identical flavor, thus either one may be used in its place.

What can I use instead of porcini mushrooms?

In addition to these other potential choices, you may also think about using thyme. In recipes that call for porcini mushrooms, this is a fantastic substitute when you want the dish to have a subtle, earthy scent. In addition to that, it is an excellent addition to stews, soups, and chili.

What’s the difference between porcini and Portobello mushrooms?

The family to which each of these mushrooms belongs is the primary distinction between them. Portobello mushrooms are the mature form of the Cremini species, while porcini are classified as Boelusedulis. Porcini mushrooms are smaller in size compared to portobello mushrooms.


Even if you run out of porcini mushrooms, you can never run out of options for your favorite creamy soups or meat kebabs. If you use one of these other ingredients instead of the one called for in the recipe, you can get it back to how it was supposed to turn out. In addition, all of the solutions are reasonably priced and simple to locate, which means that picking them will save you time, effort, and energy.