Site Overlay

Substitute for Butter in the Frosting

Rate this post

Butter is a fundamental component in many recipes, but it thrives the most in baking, while being utilized in many cooking methods. It’s almost difficult to bake without butter, and it’s a versatile ingredient that provides delicate tastes as well as unusual smooth and creamy textures.

Frosting is one of the baking recipes that calls for butter. Butter is often combined with other ingredients to create a smooth and creamy frosting for a cake, cupcakes, or any other pastry. Butter is a frequent item, but it is simple to run out of it, or you may wish to reduce the amount of fat it contains. Whatever reason you need a replacement is essential to you, and we will look at several in this post.

What is Butter?

Substitute for Butter in the Frosting

Because butter is such a popular product, everyone is familiar with it. Butter is manufactured from the protein and fat content of churned cow’s milk or cream; however, milk from other animals such as buffalo, sheep, and goat may also be utilized. Instead, the milk or cream is put in a churn and swirled or shaken to create the semi-solid butter mixture.

Butter is versatile and may be used in a variety of culinary ways. It is used in sautéing and high-heat cooking, as a spread on bread, and in a variety of baking dishes. Despite its high calorie content, butter contains nutrients such as antioxidants, vitamin E, K, A, and B12, which are responsible for good eyesight, immunological health, skin health, heart health, and cell protection. It also includes nutrients such as CLA, butyrate, and trace amounts of calcium, riboflavin, niacin, vitamin D, and phosphorus.

Whey butter, cultured butter, sweet cream butter, clarified butter, European butter, and more forms of butter are available.

Butter Uses in Recipes

Substitute for Butter in the Frosting

Butter is used in the culinary world in both liquid and solid forms. It is melted and used in sauces, as well as in sauteing and frying dishes, while the semi-solid forms are baked with other components. Butter contains subtle qualities that give foods, particularly baked ones, a distinct flavor.

If you just use butter as a spread or as an occasional component in meals, here are some additional tasty recipes to try with it.

  • Charred Brussels Sprouts With Spicy Anchovy
  • Ravioli With Beets, Butter, And Poppy Seeds
  • Griller Oysters With Bloody Mary Butter
  • Caf De Paris Butter
  • Butternut Pancakes With Sage Brown Butter
  • Caramelized Onion Butter
  • Alain Ducasses Foie Gras Butter
  • Grilled Pork T-Bones With BBQ Butter
  • Prosciutto Missy Robbins With Parmesan Butter And Baldamic Mustard
  • Pasta with Squid Ink, Seafood, Burst Tomatoes, and Sea Urchin Butter
  • Caviar Butter
  • Strip Steaks With Bouillabaisse Butter
  • Ribeye Steaks With Pistachio Butter And Asparagus
  • Smoked Polenta With Sage Browned Butter
  • Pumpkin Honey Butter
  • Banana Bread Bars With Brown Butter Frosting

Butter Substitutes

Butter is an essential element in the kitchen. The most significant aspect of butter is the texture and structure it lends to dishes, particularly baked ones. Because of its distinctive characteristic, almost all baked products need this Ingredient, and butter is responsible for the fluffy and moist texture of baked goods.

Many people are aware of the benefits of butter, but it is not the ideal choice for everyone, including those who are allergic to dairy, vegans, and individuals on a low-fat diet. This would not be an issue since butter can be readily substituted in many recipes, and nothing beats butter. Still, these substitutes will have a texture, flavor, and structure close to butter and will perform well in frosting recipes.

Coconut Cream

Coconut cream is your best bet if you’re seeking for a vegan and lactose-free solution. Coconut cream is a thickened and concentrated form of coconut milk that lends smooth and creamy textures to dishes and works well as a vegan icing.

To make it, put it in the refrigerator overnight to chill but not freeze, then drain any extra water in the morning. Instead, add the cooled coconut cream in a mixing dish and beat it to the desired fluffy consistency. If you want to go more creative, try adding flavors like vanilla or chocolate. One thing to keep in mind is that the frosting will have a coconut flavor, which won’t be an issue if you don’t mind the flavor.

This frosting process is widely used on the Internet, and you might experiment with different modifications to determine what works best for you.

Cream Cheese

Cream cheese is another popular butter alternative in baked products and frostings. Cream cheese has a moderate flavor and a delicate texture, but it is not a vegan or lactose-free option manufactured from milk and cream.

American cream cheese is lower in fat than other varieties and lends a creamy feel to sauces and baked products.

Low-fat cream cheese is better for cooking, while full-fat cream cheese is thicker and creamier and works well in frostings and other baked goods.

Because of its creamy texture, the creamy cheese may be difficult to pipe into baked items. Still, according to Sally’s Baking Addiction, the cream cheese may be put in a piping bag and chilled for 15-30 minutes before adding to your baked dish. This would give it the same structure as buttercream.


Avocado frosting has become a popular lactose-free and vegan icing in the culinary world. Avocado’s rich, nutritious fats combine with cocoa powder, maple syrup, vanilla extract, and salt to create creamy, delectable, and healthful frostings.

8 tsp salt.4 teaspoons pure vanilla extract 6-8 tbsp pure maple syrup or other sweetener of choice 1 pound cocoa powder 1Two ripe avocados, 1 teaspoon cocoa powder, and 1 teaspoon cocoa powder

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can margarine be used in place of butter?

Margarine is often used as a replacement for butter, but when shopping for margarine, search for varieties that are low in saturated fat and low in trans fat.

Can oils be used to substitute butter in frosting?

Olive oil may be substituted for butter to get an excellent outcome, but it will not be as fluffy as buttercream.

What can other Ingredients be substituted for butter in frosting to make it thick?

Frostings may be thickened with cornstarch and sugar, or they can be frozen before use.


Butter is a typical element in the making of frostings, and it also adds structure and flavor to baked products, but if you’re out of it or prefer another item, there are several suitable substitutes.


How do you thicken frosting without butter?

Cornstarch may help thicken the icing without changing the taste too much. Begin by mixing in 1 teaspoon of cornstarch per cup of frosting. If necessary, gradually add additional cornstarch until the required consistency is attained.

What is a substitute for margarine in frosting?

Substitute 1 cup of the following for 1 cup margarine: 1 cup softened cream cheese (or one 8-oz. block) or reduced-fat cream cheese (less calories and fat). 1 cup trans-fat-free vegetable oil spread or olive oil spread (60 to 70%).

Can you replace butter with shortening in frosting?

Can I use butter instead of shortening? Yes, you may use butter instead of shortening. BUT you will be sacrificing taste and texture.

What is best butter substitute?

The following items, in general, perform well as butter substitutes in cakes, muffins, cookies, brownies, and quick breads:
Applesauce. Applesauce decreases the calorie and fat content of baked foods substantially.
Bananas mashed.
Yogurt from Greece.
Butters made from nuts.
Purée of pumpkin.

What ingredients thicken frosting?

Slowly incorporating powdered sugar is the finest and simplest technique to thicken frosting. However, there are several additional options to attempt, such as adding butter, shortening, cream cheese, whipped cream, flour, cornstarch, and other ingredients.

Can I use vegetable oil instead of butter?

In a recipe, replace 4 of the butter with olive, canola, or vegetable oil (if the recipe asks for 1 cup butter, use 34 cup oil). When it comes to coconut oil, you may utilize a 1:1 ratio.Oil in Place of Butter

A reasonable rule of thumb is to replace about three

What can I use instead of vegan butter in icing?

2 Earth Balance to equal the fat content and consistency of stick margarine.2 tablespoons coconut oil or vegetable shortening and 1You may use vegan margarine like Earth Balance or a similar, but you must use 1 cup.

Can you substitute margarine in buttercream?

Butter is essential for a rich and creamy taste in your frosting. For consistently delicious results, we recommend using high-quality unsalted butter. If you must use margarine, choose standard margarine rather than low-fat margarine.

Which shortening is best for frosting?

High ratio shortening may also improve the taste and texture of your products. Use it to make a buttercream frosting or use it to make the cake itself. Because high ratio shortening is less greasy than other shortenings, it produces a lovely and smooth consistency when used to make icing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *