Site Overlay

Spicy Brown Mustard Substitute

Rate this post

It’s no secret that mustard has become a staple in contemporary cooking, whether drizzled over a newly cooked hotdog, emulsified in a salad dressing, or spread on a sandwich. Spicy Brown Mustard contains brown mustard seeds that have been steeped in less vinegar than standard mustard seeds. The combination of hotter seeds and lesser acidity amplifies the nose-scorching heat dramatically.


Consider the following options for a spicy brown mustard substitute. Honey mustard, Dijon mustard, whole grain mustard, horseradish sauce, and horseradish sauce. But which of them is the best choice for your recipe? Continue reading to learn more! This spicy mustard substitute may cut through the fattiness of the meat and stands up well against deli meats of various flavors. Chefs like spicy brown mustard, which pairs well with horseradish.

What are Some Substitutes for Spicy Brown Mustard?

Spicy Brown Mustard Substitute

  • Dijon Mustard

If you can’t have spicy brown mustard, a Dijon-style mustard replacement could be your best solution. If you don’t like the acidic flavor, use yellow mustard instead. Yellow mustard has a milder flavor than Dijon mustard but the same creamy texture. It can also be used in recipes that call for Dijon mustard. Here are some suggestions to help you choose a suitable substitute.

Wasabi may be used in lieu of Dijon mustard. It has a similar flavor and spice as Dijon and may be used in roasted potatoes and Asian meals. Mayonnaise is another great choice. It tastes like Dijon mustard, but with a kick. Wasabi has a strong spicy flavor that pairs well with meat. It’s also great in salad dressings. Mayonnaise, on the other hand, does not have the same flavor as Dijon.

  • Whole Grain Mustard

If you don’t like Dijon or whole grain mustard, try yellow, Dijon, honey, or spicy brown mustard. Whole grain mustard, made from mustard seeds and vinegar, is a gentler alternative to spicy brown mustard, with a Dijon-like flavor that works well in sandwiches and salad dressings. Whole grain mustard may be used in marinades and sauces as well.

Spicy brown mustard has a stronger flavor than yellow mustard since it is made from spicy brown mustard seeds. Because the seeds are coarsely crushed with their outer husks intact, the mustard will have a gritty texture. Some producers add chili peppers and cayenne pepper to this mustard, which you may customize to your liking. There are several benefits to using this mustard substitute, but you should be aware of its downsides.

  • Horseradish Sauce

For those who are allergic to horseradish, there are many alternatives. This paste, made from a spicy powder known as brown mustard, works well as a replacement for horseradish. It has a horseradish flavor and a greater spice concentration than yellow mustard. To make horseradish paste, combine two teaspoons mustard powder and a few drops of water. Horseradish paste may also be made using one teaspoon of prepared horseradish paste and half a teaspoon of water.

While horseradish sauce may be substituted with spicy brown mustard, the essential intensity is lost. Although spicy brown mustard lacks the strength of dijon mustard, the heat in substantial sandwiches helps to cut through the fat. Chefs use it as a seasoning that complements the flavors of deli meats. It’s also a great complement to sandwiches and a popular horseradish substitute. Horseradish, on the other hand, will increase the flavor of the meal.

  • Honey Mustard

Honey mustard is a delightful alternative to Dijon mustard. This creamy, sweet sauce complements grilled or roasted meats as well as salads, dips, and other foods. Horseradish sauce may also be used for Dijon mustard. Horseradish is a root that has a milder flavor than Dijon since it is flavored with vinegar, salt, and cream.

Honey mustard is made by combining equal parts mustard and honey. Depending on your tastes, the ratio may be raised or lowered. The most popular mustard used for honey mustard is yellow mustard, and the mix of sweet and spicy neutralizes the harshness of yellow mustard. Honey mustard is excellent for dipping and sauces. Wasabi is another option for a sweet taste boost, and it incorporates mustard crushed into it.

  • Wagarashi

You’ve most likely heard of Chinese mustard, but you’ve most likely never eaten Japanese mustard. Wagarashi, made from powdered brown mustard seeds and water, is a comparable substitute. Unlike English mustard, which is yellow, Japanese mustard is spicy. It may be used as a dipping sauce, seasoning, or to season meals. It’s also great for cooking since it contains antioxidants.

This Japanese mustard has a unique texture and flavor, as well as a hint of spice. This brownish-red color compliments meat dishes well. It has a vinegary flavor, although it isn’t as potent as Chinese hot mustard. It is recommended to use spicy mustard to improve the flavor of meat dishes. This alternative is often used in Asian cuisine and may simply be changed for English mustard if you want your mustard spicy.

Is Dijon Mustard Spicy Brown Mustard?

Dijon mustard isn’t as spicy as brown mustard, but still packs a punch. Both utilize brown mustard seeds (or black for a spicy brown). Dijon mustard seeds are soaked in white wine or a similar liquid, while spicy brown mustard seeds are soaked in vinegar. Dijon mustard complements marinades and sauces, while spicy brown mustard complements big, meat-filled sandwiches.

Dijon Mustard

The brand was founded in Dijon, France, in 1865. The bulk of it is now produced outside of Dijon. Vinegar was used in place of verjuice (an acidic juice derived from unripe grapes) in the original recipe. It is now prepared using white wine or similar low-acidity beverage. Brown or black mustard seeds are used to produce this meal, and they may be used everywhere yellow mustard is used to provide a stronger mustardy taste. In vinaigrettes and sauces, I like to combine it with mayonnaise.

Spicy brown mustard

The deeper color is due to a large proportion of brown mustard seeds. Before used, mustard seeds are soaked in vinegar. Because the bran is left on the seeds, the texture is rougher and thicker. The flavor is really intense. Wasabi, arugula, and horseradish are all linked. It’s popular in Indian, Chinese, and Japanese cuisines. This deli mustard goes well with pastrami, roast beef, or corned beef.

What does Brown Mustard Taste Like?

Most people think spicy brown mustard tastes like a delicious combination of horseradish and garlic. It’s hotter than its milder equivalent, but not as hot as the other options on this list. When used in sandwiches, this mustard has a lot going for it since the spice will gently melt into anything else you put inside your sandwich.

Modern Americans, on the other hand, have become used to a sweetened version with extra sugar or honey for flavor. Today’s grocery shelves are filled with a variety of mustards, including whole-grain and spicy varieties, making them versatile in their use.

Mustard is made by crushing mustard seeds until the seed coverings are cracked and a paste-like material, similar to peanut butter or garlic powder, remains. After that, the pulverized mustard seed combination may be blended with water to create an acidic liquid with a buttermilk-like consistency.

Does Spicy Mustard have Horseradish?

Mustard seed is the primary component in spicy brown mustard. The mustard seed used to manufacture it contains the largest percentage of myrosinase, an enzyme that generates heat when broken and combined with liquid, giving it a horseradish-like heat. These brown mustard seeds, derived from the Brassica juncea mustard plant, provide significantly more strong mustard than the yellow seed used in American yellow hot dog mustard.

Taste intensity may favor strong-flavored foods such as roast beef or pastrami. If you don’t have any spicy brown mustard on hand, there’s still hope. Other alternatives may provide some of the same tastes.

Is Dijon Mustard the Same as Spicy Brown Mustard?

If you like spicy foods, try spicy brown mustard as an alternative to Dijon. Before being processed, the brown seeds are soaked in less vinegar, resulting in a peppery condiment. Because of the way it is processed, spicy brown mustard has the same texture as Dijon mustard.

Spicy brown mustard is made using brown mustard seeds and less vinegar than regular yellow mustard. Furthermore, the bran from the mustard seeds is not removed, which contributes to its abrasive feel as compared to yellow and other mustards.

Spicy Brown mustard seeds, soaked with less vinegar than standard mustard seeds, are utilized. Spicy brown mustard also has a coarser texture than yellow mustard because the bran on the seeds does not completely break down during processing.

Both utilize brown mustard seeds (or black for a spicy brown). Dijon mustard seeds are soaked in white wine or a similar liquid, while spicy brown mustard seeds are soaked in vinegar. Dijon mustard complements marinades and sauces, while spicy brown mustard complements big, meat-filled sandwiches.

What is the Difference Between Dijon Mustard and Spicy Brown Mustard?

Brown mustard seeds are used in both (or black for a spicy brown). Dijon mustard seeds are soaked in white wine or a similar liquid, whereas spicy brown mustard seeds are soaked in vinegar. Dijon mustard pairs nicely with marinades and sauces, while spicy brown mustard complements big, meat-filled sandwiches.

Dijon mustard is creamier and milder in flavor than spicy brown mustard. Dijon mustard, on the other hand, has a stronger flavor than spicy brown mustard since it is made with black mustard seeds rather than white and brown seeds. Despite the fact that they are both named mustard, they are significantly different.

Brown mustard is stronger and more flavorful than dijon mustard, which is gentler. It’s famous for its spiciness and biting. A suitable substitute should be able to provide the same quantity of heat. Horseradish has a robust flavor that blends well with other components. To substitute solely the spicy brown mustard flavors, simply add prepared horseradish or freshly ground horseradish root to the recipe. To get the desired consistency, horseradish may alternatively be combined with sour cream.

In What Recipes Spicy Brown Mustard is Used?

  • Roasts

A mustard dressing is a staple for soft greens, but it also pairs well with sweet roasted parsnips and turnips or sour coleslaw. Bake the mustard dressing first for a thicker, less oily mustard dressing. The mustard should, indeed, be cooked.

Rub herby mustard on a leg of lamb, pig loin, or turkey breast before roasting to produce a beautiful crust.

To add acidity to a cream sauce for pasta, add a few spoonfuls of grainy mustard.

  • Mashed Potatoes

To cut through the richness of the mashed potatoes, add some mustard. After that, the bacon should be sprinkled on top.

Salmon and tuna, for example, go well with mustard crusts. Brush it on before broiling salmon fillets or grilling tuna.


If you don’t have the materials to create your own mustard, or if you need to omit mustard from a recipe owing to dietary constraints or personal preferences, you may use a replacement. When creating a successful substitute, it is important to consider how the mustard is used in the recipe. Mustard adds flavor to dishes, but it may also be used as a thickener or emulsifier (something that holds oil and vinegar together). Related to this post is Substitute Maple Syrup for Brown Sugar

It is also critical to consider how much mustard you will need. Yellow mustard has a mild flavor, but Dijon or whole seed mustard is stronger. Taking this into account allows you to choose the closest match in terms of taste.


Can I substitute Dijon mustard for spicy brown mustard?

Brown mustard with a spicy kick

It’s spicier than Dijon and has a more textured look (not as smooth). You may substitute it 1:1, but bear in mind that it adds some heat to the dish. If you’re cooking for somebody who can’t take heat, you may want to forgo this choice.

What is considered spicy brown mustard?

Mustard, Spicy Brown

Spicy brown mustards are often ground coarser than yellow or Dijon mustards, and many bottled types mix brown seeds, yellow seeds, and spices such as ginger, nutmeg, or cinnamon.

Can you use yellow mustard instead of brown mustard?

Yellow mustard seeds have a tangier flavor than brown mustard seeds. When switching one for the other, the brown mustard is more pungent, so you don’t need as much as you would with yellow seeds. Here’s an excellent recipe for Homemade Spicy Mustard.

Is spicy brown mustard the same as ground mustard?

The seeds are white. With more heat and taste than yellow mustard, this is a popular condiment at many delis as well as the ubiquitous New York City hot dog vendor.Spicy Brown: This has a little coarser grind than yellow or Dijon and contains some of the spicy brown mustard seeds as well as the normal yellow mustard seeds.

What is the difference in Dijon mustard and spicy brown mustard?

The liquid in which the pulverized mustard seed plants are mixed is what distinguishes spicy mustard from Dijon. Dijon mustard seeds are often blended with unripe grapes, while spicy brown mustard employs vinegar, resulting in a distinct taste character.

Can I turn yellow mustard into Dijon mustard?

Dijon mustard cannot be manufactured from yellow mustard since the components are different. If you just have standard yellow mustard on hand and need or prefer Dijon mustard, consider mixing in a little mayonnaise.

Is there horseradish in spicy brown mustard?

The Enzyme Effect. The main component in Chinese mustard is mustard seed. Its horseradish-like heat is caused by the mustard seed used to make it, which is rich in myrosinase, an enzyme that produces heat when broken and combined with liquid.

Why do I crave spicy brown mustard?

It turns out that our need for diversity is encoded into our DNA. So when we try something new, such as hot mustard or sweet honey-mustard dressing, our brain produces dopamine, which produces good sensations and makes us desire more. Our forefathers relished mustard, and you can, too!

What’s another name for brown mustard?

Canola refers to juncea and oil seed cultivars of the allied plants B. napus and B. rapa. “Brown mustard,” “Indian mustard,” and “oilseed mustard” are among more frequent names.

Can you substitute dry mustard for brown mustard?

1 teaspoon dry mustard is equal to 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard.

This substitute is suitable for the majority of recipes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *