Site Overlay

Replacement for Scotch Bonnet Pepper

Rate this post

2 inches in length. The Scotch Bonnet pepper is a key element in Jamaican Jerk spice and sauce, as well as Jamaican cuisines. Scotch Bonnet chilies are very common in most well-stocked supermarkets. The Scotch Bonnet pepper is a very fiery chili related to the habanero. It has a Scoville rating of 100,000 to 350,000 units and a relative heat rating of 9-10. The hue of the chile may range from yellow-green to orange and even blazing red. This chile is about 1 to 1 12 inches in length.


Scotch Bonnet Peppers are called after Scotsmen since the Brits introduced the pepper to Jamaica in the mid-nineteenth century. The pepper is also known as a Caribbean red pepper since it originated on the Caribbean island of Jamaica, where it is a key component in jerk sauce.

Scotch bonnet peppers have a spicy, delicious taste with citrus and mango undertones. You may eat them fresh or prepare them into soups, stews, and curries.

They are also low in nutrients and calories when compared to other peppers, which means they may provide zest to your dish without adding calories.

Why do we need to scotch bonnet pepper substitutes?

Although Scotch bonnet peppers are a great option for heat and a delicious taste, they might be difficult to locate in places with a low Caribbean population. Since most stores do not stock them, they might be difficult to locate. This might be an issue if you wish to utilize a recipe that calls for this pepper. But, there are various viable substitutes for Scotch bonnet peppers that will guarantee your food tastes just as good as if you used the genuine thing.

Substitute for Scotch Bonnet Peppers

If you’re searching for Scotch bonnet replacements to spice up your dish, we’ve gathered a list of options that you may use instead!

Cayenne Pepper

Cayenne peppers are a common addition in a variety of recipes. These may be used in place of the hot and spicy Scotch bonnet pepper.

Cayenne peppers have a Scoville heat index that varies from 30,000 to 50,000 SHU (Scoville Heat Units). Scotch Bonnets vary in heat from 100,000 to 350,000 SHU.

Cayenne Peppers may not have the same amount of heat as Scotch Bonnets, but they do have some spice to them and can contribute flavor without dominating other components or being too spicy for most people.

Fresno Peppers

Scotch Bonnet peppers are often hotter than Fresno peppers. Yet, both types offer a powerful punch that may be too much for some.

If you want to use them in meals that will be cooked at low heat and not eaten whole, Fresno peppers are a better choice. They have an earthy taste that may greatly complement the food!

Habanero pepper

Some of you may be asking whether habanero peppers may be used in place of scotch bonnets. Certainly, however you must exercise great caution while dealing with this pepper, particularly if it is used in a dish that demands a lengthy cooking time. Moreover, habanero lacks the true depth of flavor that few great scotch bonnets offer. As a result, habanero does not make an ideal alternative for meals that call for the full potential of scotch bonnet peppers.

Habanero peppers, on the other hand, are a fantastic replacement that has a similar taste profile. They’re also a great substitute for scotch bonnet peppers if you want something spicy but not overpowering.

Pequin Peppers

Pequin peppers are far more frequent than scotch bonnets and have a similar spicy profile but without the heat. They also have a sweeter taste, making them ideal for recipes like mole or tamales that need sweetness.

By substituting pequin peppers for scotch bonnets, you may transform your recipe while retaining its original taste character!

Pequin peppers are milder than scotch bonnets and may be used in place of them to lessen the heat level.

Serrano Peppers

The Scotch Bonnet pepper is a capsicum with a Scoville rating of 100,000 or more. The Serrano pepper, on the other hand, has a price range of 1,600-2,500.

So, what does all of this mean? If you’re switching peppers for another dish and want to make it hotter without increasing the overall heat, consider a Serrano instead of a Scotch Bonnet.

You’ll receive the same taste profile but with less spice!

Thai Peppers


Thai peppers are related to Scotch bonnet peppers. They have a comparable amount of heat and taste, but with a lower intensity.

Thai chiles may be used in place of Scotch bonnets in many recipes, as long as you minimize the quantity of seeds while cooking them.

They may be obtained in grocery shops’ produce sections or Asian markets. By substituting Thai peppers for Scotch Bonnet peppers, you may change the taste of your meal without sacrificing the fire!

Rocotillo pepper

Rocotillo pepper is a Scotch Bonnet variation that is characterized as a goat head pepper. Rocotillos are more delicious than scotch bonnets, although their flavors are comparable.

It starts as green but eventually becomes red or orange. Rocotillos may grow up to 2 inches long and feature a hole in the centre where the spine protrudes. Whilst the spines are not usually harmful to people, they may create difficulties in animals, so exercise caution if you have a pet at home.

Others claim that Rocotillo peppers have the most scotch bonnet-like aroma and the fiercest burn of any Scotch Bonnet kind. These are an excellent option for scotch bonnets, particularly if you want a somewhat pungent and tasty pepper that is fairly spicy, but keep in mind that these peppers are not for the faint of heart!

Substitute for Scotch Bonnet Peppers in Mango Kuchela

Trindad’s Mango Kuchela is prepared with air-dried green mango, fiery chile peppers, vinegar, salt, spices, and brown sugar. The spicy relish goes well with anything from rice to curry. The habanero pepper is an excellent alternative for scotch bonnet in this recipe since it cooks faster and has a similar flavor profile.

Substitute for Scotch Bonnet Peppers in Jamaican Jerk Spice

This spicy Jamaican Jerk Spice blend is often used to season pork or poultry in Jamaica. This rub is dry at times and paste at others. Refrigerate for up to three months. Thai pepper may easily replace scotch bonnet in this recipe since they have the same hotness level and can withstand the shelf life of this dish.

Frequently Asked Question [FAQs]

Is scotch bonnet good for you?

They are, indeed. Scotch bonnet peppers are high in vitamin A, C, B, phytochemicals, and other nutrients.

How to store Scotch Bonnet Peppers?

There are many methods to keep these spicy peppers so that they don’t go bad. One method is to store them in oil or vinegar, which will maintain their taste for up to six months. Another alternative is to freeze them in ice cube trays with some oil inside for later use in scotch bonnet dishes.

Which is hotter habanero or scotch bonnet?

The scotch bonnet is more potent. The habanero chili pepper has around 260,000 SHU, but the scotch bonnet pepper has approximately 445,000 SHU.

Scotch Bonnet Peppers are waxy orbs that come in a variety of sizes and have a distinct appearance that is unlike any other pepper in the world. They are of Caribbean descent and are popular in various parts of the globe, such as Africa and Brazil.


What can I use instead of a scotch bonnet pepper?

15 Greatest Scotch Bonnet Pepper Replacements
Peppers with a jalapeo kick.
Habanero peppers.
Thai chilies.
Cayenne peppers are spicy peppers.
Tabasco sauce.
Serrano Chiles.
The Anaheim Peppers.
Poblano peppers.
More to come…
•Nov 7, 2022

Are scotch bonnets and habaneros the same thing?

These chilis have varying degrees of heat, but their flavors are also distinct. Habaneros have a somewhat sweet and fruity flavor that is slightly bitter. Scotch Bonnets are similarly sweet and delicious, but not bitter. Individuals who are inexperienced with the various chili heat levels and tastes will detect no change.

Which is hotter jalapeno or scotch bonnet?

The scotch bonnet may be up to 40 times hotter than a regular jalapeo pepper, with a heat level of 100,000-350,000 scoville units.

What is scotch bonnet pepper compared to?

Scotch bonnet peppers are 12 to 140 times hotter than jalapeos. It’s also 2 to 12 times hotter than the cayenne pepper in your spice cabinet. That’s a big increase in heat. Of course, there are more hotter chiles on the Scoville scale than the scotch bonnet.

What is scotch bonnet pepper called in America?

Scotch bonnet (also known as Bonney peppers or Caribbean red peppers) is a kind of chili pepper named after the Scottish tam o’ shanter hat.

What can I use instead of scotch bonnet pepper in jerk chicken?

If you can’t locate Scotch bonnets, use habanero peppers instead.

Can habanero be substituted for scotch bonnet?

Habanero chilies.

The habanero pepper is the greatest scotch bonnet alternative. They are not only extremely comparable to scotch bonnets in taste and heat intensity, but they are also considerably simpler to get. Habanero peppers may be substituted 1:1.

What flavor is scotch bonnet pepper?

What Do You Think It Tastes Like? Scotch bonnets are quite hot peppers, yet they may have an almost sweet, faintly fruity flavor below the spiciness. This might vary from place to region since it is dependent on the soil conditions in which they are cultivated.

Is scotch bonnet the same as Carolina Reaper?

The Carolina Reaper packs roughly a 15th of the punch of a scotch bonnet pepper, yet it burns about 15 times as hot as a scotch bonnet pepper. Jalapenos, a mild pepper, provide around 1 teaspoon of heat.

Is scotch bonnet hotter than habanero?

The term “Scotch bonnet” may seem innocuous, but these peppers carry a punch. Habaneros and Scotch Bonnets are relatives with comparable heat levels ranging from 100,000 to 350,000 on the Scoville heat scale.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *