Site Overlay

Replace corn syrup in pecan pie

Rate this post

Pecan pie is a kind of pie prepared with pecan nuts. Pecan is a healthy nut native to Mexico and the southern United States that is high in vitamins and minerals. These healthful Pecan nuts may be turned into a pie by combining sugar, milk, vanilla extract, and, most significantly, corn syrup.


Pecan pie is a nutritious meal since pecans are abundant in protein and potassium. It’s also a treat to consume since it has the texture of crunchy candy (thanks to the nuts) with all the gooeyness that comes with it. This explosion of flavor in your tongue is what makes Pecan pie such a sweet treat.

Corn syrup is crucial in Pecan pie since it functions as a sweetener and provides your pie a beautiful texture that isn’t gritty. This is accomplished by avoiding sugar crystallization during baking. Nonetheless, depending on your goals for your meals, it is essential to understand the various forms of corn syrups and how they are employed.

What is Corn Syrup? 

Several confectioners produce this kind of food syrup from maize starch, which is also known as glucose syrup. It’s made by combining dilute acid with maize starch (hydrolysis) and heating it. When cornstarch isn’t available, we may substitute wheat, rice, or potatoes. Apart from hydrolysis, various enzymes are used in the production of corn syrup.

Corn syrup is offered in two varieties: dark and light syrup. Both are used in the same manner, with the exception of the taste or color when added to recipes. Dark syrup is generally sweetened by the addition of molasses and caramel coloring. There is also HFCS syrup, which is derived from corn syrup (high fructose corn syrup). It has a high sugar content and is sweeter than conventional corn syrup. As a result, it is essential to store corn syrup properly, in a well sealed container at room temperature or, if desired, refrigerated.

Corn Syrup Nutrition Facts

Uses of Corn Syrup in Recipes

In nations such as the United States, high fructose corn syrup is used as a sweetener in lieu of sugar in a variety of recipes. Corn syrup is more harmful than sugar, and HFCS is not the same as corn syrup but is manufactured from it. For example, in the soft drink sector, Corn Syrup may be utilized in a variety of baked products after being processed differently. Corn syrup is often offered as a dry powder that has been transformed into syrup. Here are a few pecan pie recipes to try today:

  • Cake with pecan pie filling
  • Pecan pie with salted bourbon crust
  • Pie with chocolate and pecans
  • Pecan pie in the crockpot
  • Pie with oatmeal and pecans
  • Muffins with pecan pie filling
  • Tarts with pecan pie
  • Cobbler with pecan pie
  • Pie with chocolate pretzels and pecans
  • Pie with sweet potatoes and pecans
  • Pie with maple nuts and pecans
  • Pie with dark rum and pecans
  • Cookies with pecans in them
  • Pie with Chocolate Chips and Pecans
  • Pie with Coconut-Pecan Turtle Cream Cheese

Substitutes for Corn Syrup in Pecan Pie

Raw Honey

Corn syrup is often used as a filler to give your pies a firm grip and texture. Nevertheless, raw honey works just as well since it adds sweetness to your pecan pie while still being a nutritious option.

Honey may not be as flavorful as conventional corn syrup. Nonetheless, you probably won’t notice much of a change in your pecan pie. Instead, honey may be used in lieu of light corn syrup in recipes at a 1: 1 ratio. Its accessibility also makes it a viable replacement, particularly when Corn syrup is unavailable.

Maple Syrup

However a thinner syrup than corn syrup works well as a substitute. It’s an excellent replacement when combined with flour. The disadvantage is that it may come with an unwanted taste.

Golden Syrup

This is a thick syrup that is sweetened with cane sugar or sugar beet juice. It tastes like butter and is naturally thicker than corn syrup. When maize syrup is utilized as a replacement, there are no specific advantages that outweigh the disadvantages. Nevertheless, imagine you need to adapt since you can’t get corn syrup soon. In such instance, the Golden syrup is unquestionably effective.

It is vital to remember that when using Golden syrup instead of corn syrup, the taste may vary.

Frequently asked Questions (FAQs)

Why are my Pecan pies runny? 

Running pecan pie is caused by not baking it long enough at the correct temperature. Thus, if you want to make a fantastic pecan pie, bake it for 60-70 minutes at about 177 degrees Celsius, then lay it aside to cool and set.

Is Light or Dark Syrup better for Pecan pie? 

Both may be used interchangeably, with the only difference being the desired flavor. Dark Syrup has a more robust flavor. Nonetheless, the light syrup works better if you want a light but sweet flavor, nearly like vanilla.

Why is corn syrup not good for you?

Corn syrup, like many sugary foods, is not as healthful as alternative replacements since excessive sugar consumption is linked to a variety of health concerns. This is due to corn syrup’s high fructose content. When ingested in large quantities, fructose may promote insulin resistance, which can lead to diabetes.

Hence, limiting the quantity of corn syrup you put in your dessert can help you stay healthy.


Assume you’re making a pecan pie for the holidays. You’re searching for healthier replacements to employ, particularly because you know not everyone can tolerate such a high sugar level. In such instance, the desire for a less harmful sweetener may come in helpful. Moreover, these easily accessible options make it even more handy for those occasions when you run out of corn syrup and must improvise. See all of your meals come out appetizing and nutritious, with the addition of fresh tastes to make everything a delicacy.


What can I use instead of corn syrup in a pie?

Maple Syrup has 5 corn syrup substitutes. In pies, cakes, or any dish where a delicate maple taste is desired, substitute equal quantities maple syrup for light or dark corn syrup.
Honey. Brown Rice Syrup. Golden Syrup. Cane Sugar Syrup.
Jul 30, 2022

Why does pecan pie need corn syrup?

Corn syrup isn’t simply utilized as a sweetener in pecan pie. It also prevents sugar crystallization during baking, resulting in a smooth texture in the filling. Nobody wants a stale pie!

What can I use instead of corn syrup for cake?

4 cup warm water.
1 cup honey.
1 cup molasses (mild).
1 cup flavored maple syrup (pancake syrup)
1 cup agave nectar.
1 cup brown rice syrup.
Dec 27, 2022
1 cup corn syrup may be replaced with one of the following easy substitutes:
1 cup sugar dissolved in 1 cup water

Which of the following is the best substitute for corn syrup?

Water and Sugar

A modified simple syrup of four parts sugar to one part warm water is an easy corn syrup substitute in many recipes, including soft-ball-stage confections like buttercreams, pralines, and fudge. This flavorless substitute tastes comparable to corn syrup.

Why do you put corn syrup in a pie?

By limiting the production of sugar crystals, the syrup guarantees a smooth texture in sugar pies, pecan pie (or pecan tassies), chess pies, handmade ice creams, and sorbets.

What does corn syrup do in baking?

Corn syrup is used as a sweetener, especially when a smooth texture is required in a dish. It is known as a ‘invert sugar’ because, unlike table sugar and certain other syrups, it does not form huge, gritty crystals when allowed to cool.

Why is my homemade pecan pie runny?

If your pecan pie is runny, it’s most likely due to insufficient baking time. It should be baked for 60 to 70 minutes at 350F before being allowed to cool and set. This pecan pie recipe should not result in a runny pie.

What makes a pecan pie not set up?

A liquid core is nearly often the consequence of underbaking in a pecan pie, which is basically a custard pie. The Karo Traditional Pecan Pie recipe asks for baking the pie at 350 degrees for 60 to 70 minutes. But, in certain ovens, the pie might take 75 minutes or more.

What can I substitute for dark Karo in pecan pie?

4 cup hot water (or other liquid used in the recipe).
Dec 2, 2010
4 cup packed brown sugar dissolved with 14 molasses.
1 cup honey.
+ 1 14 cup light corn syrup
You may substitute the following ingredients for 1 cup of dark corn syrup:

Can you use cream of tartar instead of corn syrup?

Corn syrup inhibits the formation of sugar crystals. When preparing candies, a splash of lemon juice or cream of tartar, which provides virtually the same function, may be substituted. Use this recipe to make syrup.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *