Site Overlay

Pimento Pepper Substitutes

Rate this post

Pimento peppers (also known as pimento cheese) are little heart-shaped sweet peppers with a moderate flavor and minimal heat that are often put into olives. The pimento pepper (sometimes written pimiento) is another name for the cherry pepper. It’s a heart-shaped sweet pepper that’s 3-4 inches long and 2-3 inches broad, and it’s a bright red color.

Pimento is most known for the renowned pepper used to fill olives. Pimento and pimiento are both Portuguese and Spanish terms derived from the Latin word pigmentum, which meaning pigment. Long ago, the word pimento became a general name for peppers, and it was later expanded to include black pepper.

If you don’t like the flavor of fiery red peppers, try a variety of pimento pepper replacements. Red bell peppers, South African peppadew, pumpkin pie spice, and roasted red bell peppers may all be used in place of the pimento pepper. All of these peppers are easily accessible and easy to get at your local grocery. They may also be used in place of fresh pimento.

What are Some Substitutes for Pimento Pepper?

  • Pumpkin Pie Spice

If you don’t have pumpkin pie spice on hand, ground cinnamon is a great substitution. One-half teaspoon cinnamon may be used in place of one teaspoon of the spice. If you don’t have any nutmeg, replace Chinese 5 spice. Instead of vanilla essence, you may use vanilla bean seeds. Make sure to add the spice last, since it will lose its flavor if you don’t.

Sometimes pumpkin pie spice is mistaken with mixed spice. Both have the same components, however one has a greater flavor. Mixed spice, which has a mild spiciness, is another acceptable substitute. Use cautious while replacing since it has a milder flavor than pimento. Remember that crushed red pepper may be substituted for pimento. Because pimento is traditionally used in savory dishes, it may not be the best choice for all recipes.

  • Peppadew

Sweet cherry peppers are an excellent substitution for peppadews in pimento sauce. These peppers are comparable in size and color to peppadew peppers, but they do not have the same sweet spicy flavor. Sweet red bell peppers may be substituted for peppadew peppers. Both peppers are roasted before use and have the same beautiful red color.

  • South African Peppadew

A South African Peppadew pepper substitute might be a tasty and healthy alternative to conventional hot sauce. Peppadew chilli is abundant in vitamins and low in salt and sugar. Although the little pepper resembles a cherry tomato, it is not related to tomatoes. It contains 1177 Scoville Heat Units, the same as a sweet apple or poblano pepper, and is four times milder than a jalapeo pepper. You’ll like the flavor and heat no matter how you use it.

Piquante peppers were found by agriculturalists in South Africa soon after they were discovered. The new pepper quickly became popular, and many farmers were able to get seeds to cultivate it. Piquante peppers are currently sold in jars as well as as peppadew peppers. They are not as fiery as pimento peppers, making them an excellent substitute in recipes.

  • Red Bell Peppers

Pimento peppers may be used in place of red bell peppers in recipes that call for chopped bell peppers. These peppers may be purchased in jars, but they will not have the same crunch as fresh ones. If you can’t get pimento peppers, Cubanelle peppers may be used in place of red bell peppers. Despite their thin walls, these peppers maintain a fiery flavor and are delicious in salads.

These roasted peppers are affordable and widely available. They are simple to make: just drain the liquid and pat the pepper dry. Because roasted bell peppers are so ubiquitous, you may substitute them for pimento. This is the most widely available pepper on the market. It’s also a good alternative for pimento. You may also use ground allspice, cloves, and cinnamon for the entire peppers.

  • Paprika

Paprika may easily be swapped for pimento peppers if you want a sweet or spicy alternative, or if you prefer something light. Cajun spices or black pepper may be substituted for the paprika. Before you can substitute, you must first know which kind of paprika is called for in your recipe. Here are some alternatives to pimento peppers:

Pimentos may be dehydrated in the sun or dried in the oven to replace them. If you don’t have any fresh peppers on hand, you may use smoked paprika. Because smoked paprika might induce coughing fits, it is recommended to store it uncooked rather than in the refrigerator. The flavor will be unaltered for around six months.

  • Cubanelle Peppers

While Cubanelle peppers are the most common substitute for pimento pepper, chile may also be used in their place. The pepper has a moderate to medium heat level and is often used in Latin American and Caribbean cuisines. Because of its moderate heat, the pepper is not good for those who are sensitive to pimento. Pimento peppers are often seen in spice mixes with other spices such as allspice and paprika.

What does a Pimento Pepper Taste Like?

Pimento peppers, rather of being spicy, are mild, sweet, and succulent. They are often pickled, but are also wonderful fresh from the garden. Use them in Cajun Holy Trinity meals or in an amazing sofrito recipe as you would red bell peppers. The Santa Fe Grande and Floral Gem varieties, for example, pack a punch. They’re ideal for stuffing and dehydrating and grinding into chilli powders since they’re big enough.

Paprika, a well-known spice, is really created from dried pimento and other mild or sweet peppers. Pimento peppers have Scoville Units ranging from 500 to 1,000, making them one among the mildest peppers available. In comparison to the popular jalapeño pepper, which has a Scoville Heat Unit range of 2,500 to 8,000, the hottest pimento is around 5 times milder. The Piquillo Pepper, which is unique in form but similar in many other ways, is a decent heat and flavor comparison.

Is Pimento Same as Red Pepper?

According to The Food Lovers Companion, pimento (sometimes spelled pimiento) is a large red, heart-shaped sweet pepper that is 3-4 inches long and 2-3 inches broad. I had no idea paprika was created from a substantial amount of the pimento pepper crop. I learnt something new today.

However, there is a difference to be noted between pimentos and other types of red peppers. The flesh of pimentos is sweeter, more succulent, more aromatic than that of red bell peppers. To settle the wager, I think the judgment must be in favor of the plaintiffs. Pimentos aren’t always roasted red peppers.

Pimentos are often offered in tiny jars, while roasted red peppers are sold in larger containers. They also have the reddish-brown color of olives. The difference would most likely be minimal to an uneducated taste (like mine), particularly in a dish like pimento and cheese. So go ahead and have your one alcoholic drink. As an appetizer, I would recommend a dish of pimento and cheese on crackers. And I’ll get back to you later to pay my attorney’s fee. I will, as promised, labor for beer. In this case, I’ll add pimento and cheese to the bill.

Allspice vs. Pimento – What’s the Difference?

  • All Spice

A spice prepared from the dried and pulverized unripe fruit of that is reported to combine cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove flavors.

It’s an evergreen tropical American tree with aromatic fruit.

Pimento is a red sweet pepper, a cultivar of capsicum annuum, used to produce relish, packed with olives, or used as spice.

  • Pimento

Red sweet pepper, a cultivar of Capsicum annuum, is used as relish, wrapped with olives, and as a spice. The spice allspice is derived from a tropical fruit.

Allspice is a spice (uncountable); the dried and powdered unripe fruit of, supposed to combine the flavors of numerous spices, including cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. Pimento is a red sweet pepper cultivar of the capsicum annuum plant used to make relish, fill olives, and as a spice.

What Kind of Pepper is a Pimento?

Pimentos, also known as pimientos, are a sweet-flavored pepper with a medium heat level. This nightshade is also known as a cherry pepper because to its red color and spherical, heart-shaped fruit. They are typically 3 to 4 inches long and 2 to 3 inches broad, with a short, thick green stem. You may have eaten pimentos without even realizing it. In certain regions of Spain and the United States, pimentos are mixed with paprika, a popular spice made by crushing several peppers to a fine powder. Many chefs prefer the mellow, sweet flavor of pimento paprika over the heat of other spices such as cayenne pepper.

As with other peppers, the stems are discarded while cooking peppers. It is often cut and placed into Spanish or Manzanilla olives in Mediterranean cuisine. In the United States, pimento-stuffed olives are a favorite garnish for martinis, and they’re also included in the pimento bread our grandparents used to slice and serve for sandwiches.

Where to Buy Pimentos?

In the grocery store, pimentos are frequently found in jars beside the olives and pickles. They may be accessible if your grocery store has a self-service olive bar, which is always helpful since you can purchase simply what you need or taste them before purchasing a whole jar.

Fresh cherry peppers are available at bigger stores or those that have a broader range of foods. Theyre simple to locate if you know what you’re looking for.

If you like them and have enough room, you can grow them at home, but since their cycle is so lengthy, they flourish best in settings that are conducive to outdoor growth. They thrive in gardens and yards with a south- or west-facing orientation and a steady supply of water, and are ready when they exhibit their signature brilliant red tint. They are harvested at the same season as other peppers, from late summer to early October.

Making your own paprika is a fascinating culinary project that requires drying your growing peppers in the sun or on low heat in the oven, then grinding them in a blade grinder. Blanching them before dehydrating them is a great idea.

What are Some Recipes in Which Pimento Pepper is Used?

  • Make a one-pan meal

The sweetness of these peppers complements shrimp well. 15 minutes of sauteing 1 sliced carrot, 1 diced celery stalk, and 1 minced garlic clove 1 tablespoon tomato paste, 1 tablespoon oil, 2 tablespoons paprika, and 2 cups long-grain rice, cooked on medium-high. Toasting time: 2 minutes To deglaze the pan, 1 cup white wine is needed. Reduce the heat to low and add 3 cups of the heated seafood stock. On top, 6 pimento pepper rings and 2 bay leaves Cook for around 15 minutes. 1 pound peeled shrimp, cooked Cook for around 1–2 minutes. Season to taste with salt and pepper.

  • Stuff em with stuffing and bake em

Because the pepper flavor is so strong, it lingers throughout the cooking process. Bake for 45-60 minutes, or until golden brown and tender. Cooking time decreases as peppers grow.

  • Pickle those peppers

Combine 4 cups distilled white vinegar, 3 teaspoons kosher salt, and 14 cup sugar in a medium pot. Bring to a boil, stirring continually, until the salt and sugar have dissolved completely. Before serving, let it cool to room temperature. Seal the jar and put it in the fridge for at least a day before using.


Most popular cuisines and recipes are incomplete without the proper spices or seasonings. To be honest, there are many different types of peppers available (remember capsicum?) and their use varies widely based on the flavor of what you’re attempting to produce as well as the cuisine.

Pimiento is harvested and combined to make paprika. As you can see, it has several uses. However, it is not readily accessible in most parts of the world. If you can’t find pimiento or can’t figure out where to acquire it, there are a few alternatives you may try.


Is pimento the same as red bell pepper?

Red peppers that are often used in cuisine include pimento and red bell peppers. Pimento is a sweeter and softer red pepper than a red bell pepper. Red bell peppers are hotter and have a stronger taste.

Is pimento the same as roasted red peppers?

All roasted red peppers are not pimentos. Pimentos are offered in little jars, while roasted red peppers are often sold in bigger containers. They are also the little amount of red found in olives.

What is a substitute for pimentos in a casserole?

What is the finest pimento pepper substitute? Other sweet, mild peppers that work well as alternatives for pimentos include Peppadews, cherry, piquillo, Corno di toro, banana, cubanelle, Anaheim, poblano, or red bell peppers. Before using, test the heat of the peppers.

What is the alternative name for pimento?

Allspice (Pimenta dioica), often known as Jamaican pepper or pimento, is a tropical evergreen tree in the Myrtaceae family and the source of a very scented spice. The plant is indigenous to the Caribbean and Central America.

Can you substitute roasted red pepper for pimento?

Quick Answer: Roasted red peppers are often used in place of pimentos in stuffed olives (as well as other recipes that call for them). In fact, most individuals who have tried both believe that red bell peppers are the closest taste-wise substitute for pimentos.

Do pimentos taste like bell peppers?

Pimentos have a concentrated sweetness and moderate pepperiness, unlike regular grocery-store bell peppers, which are bred for size, resulting in watered-down taste.

Do pimentos taste like red peppers?

What are they like to eat? If you can’t handle chili peppers, pimentos are a sweet and moderate alternative. They are one of the mildest chilli peppers, having a Scoville heat level ranging from 100 to 500. They are similar to a sweeter and more fragrant red bell pepper.

What makes a pepper a pimento?

A pimiento is a huge, red, heart-shaped chili pepper (Capsicum annuum) that is 3 to 4 in (7 to 10 cm) long and 2 to 3 in (5 to 7 cm) broad (medium, elongate).

Is whole all spice the same as pimento?

Allspice, often known as pimento, is valued for its varied and adaptable taste. The modest brown fruit, which tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, is vital in Caribbean and Middle Eastern cookery, as well as popular in many European-style meals.

Do pimentos add flavor?

They are used in a variety of dips and spreads because they offer taste and color. They provide a sweet tang to sandwiches and burgers when mixed with mayo, spicy sauce, cheddar, and cream cheeses. Serve them as an unexpected element in soups, pasta dishes, and salads.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *