Site Overlay

Pickling Spice Replacement

Rate this post

Pickling has been a common method of food preservation over the years; pickling is the process of immersing a vegetable or even meat in vinegar or brine to extend its shelf life. However, this often alters the taste of the preserved food, thus there was a need to add flavor to the food, and so pickling spice was developed.

Nevertheless, pickling spice is not always readily accessible, which might be inconvenient if you wish to pickle some food at home. The absence of pickling spice seems like something you’ll have to live with, but maybe not. Did you know that there are other ways to season your food? I’ve put together some suitable pickling spice replacements for you.

What is Pickling Spice?

Substitute for Pickling Spice

Pickling spice is a mixture of six to eight spices that is used to season different cuisines. It is still quite frequent in pickled foods. It withstands the pickling process effectively, thus it is frequently put to the jar containing the pickled mixture. It is mostly made up of common spices and may lend a sweet and spicy taste to pickled foods.

Pickling is said to have originated about 2,400 B.C. Several millennia later, it is supposed to have originated with the ancient Mesopotamians. In the Tigris Valley, Indians were also preserving cucumbers.

Uses of Pickling Spice in Recipes

Pickling spice is the essential condiment that imparts flavor to pickled foods; without it, your pickled dishes would be bland and unappealing. Pickling spices may be used to season items other than pickled foods, such as rice and bean dishes and beef stew. Pickling spice is as healthful as it is delightful, including vitamin A, B-complex vitamins, and C. These are several applications for pickling spice:

  • Cinnamon buns
  • Beef and Mash with Black Pepper Mayonnaise
  • Traditional Beef Burgundy with Boiler Onions from California Farm
  • Salad with pickled cucumbers
  • Fullblood Wagyu Beef Short Ribs Pastrami
  • Pickled green chilies
  • Pickled sweet mango
  • Gosht Ka Achar from Hyderabad
  • Pastrami with a smoked flavor
  • Tomato Plum
  • Carrots and green chiles are delicious together.
  • Sandwich with spicy fried chicken
  • Salad with spicy cucumbers
  • Brisket of corned beef
  • Top of pickled onion

Substituting Pickling Spice

Pickling spice is often linked with pickled foods. It may, however, be used to season other foods such as corned beef and several rice and bean dishes. Pickling spice, like any other spice, will run out eventually, so be prepared and know what to do when this occurs.

It may be difficult to find a replacement for pickling spice since it must be potent enough to endure the whole pickling process. But if you run out of pickling spice, I’ve compiled a list of the finest replacements.

Homemade Pickling Spice

If you want anything done, do it yourself, as Emperor Napolon Bonaparte famously stated, and the same is true with pickling spice. The greatest pickling spice alternative needs to be one you make yourself since it is tailored to the taste you want.

Keep in mind that the primary premise for a good pickling spice is to offer that sweet and toasty taste, and keep in mind that the spices needed to make pickling spice are pretty simple to locate. You could need mustard seeds, black peppercorns, and cinnamon sticks, for example. Then add any extra spices you think are essential. Just be sure not to overdo it. Instead, when replacing, use the same measures.


Baharat, which means spices in Arabic, is a spice combination used in Middle Eastern cooking. It is a finely ground spice blend that may be used to season poultry, meat, fish, and other condiments.

It includes allspice and Sichuan peppercorns, which are also present in pickling spice; it also contains a variety of additional spices that may be used to enhance the taste of your food. When put to pickles, it can endure the pickling process and provide the flavour that pickling spice provides.

Check the spices contained in the mix to ensure it matches your cuisine when replacing since Bharats contents may vary according on the producer. When replacing pickling spice, use a less amount.

Crab Boil Seasoning

Crab boil seasoning, like pickling spice, is a spice combination that may be manufactured at home. It is a fantastic alternative for pickling spice since it includes all of the essential elements for pickling spice, including mustard seeds. It also includes cayenne pepper, which adds a fiery kick to your pickles. Apart from pickled foods, it is also a ground spice that may be used as a condiment for various sorts of cuisine. The substitution should be in the same proportions as a pickling spice.

Summer Savory 

Savory spice has become a culinary staple all across the globe. Its delightful scent may also be used as a replacement for pickling spices if you run out. Summer savory has a strong taste and a spicy scent, making it suitable for seasoning pickled vegetables. It also has a moderate peppery taste that makes it suitable for substituting pickling spice in the seasoning of other types of foods. It has a softness that will make your meal taste like it was prepared by a professional chef.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What liquid is used in pickling?

The best liquid for pickling is distilled white vinegar with a strong taste. You may also make your brine solution using soft or distilled water and salt.

Why do you boil vinegar when pickling?

Boiling your vinegar or brine can help the flavors mingle correctly, but avoid submerging your pickle topic in this hot solution since it will partially cook the item, and you want your pickles to preserve some crunchy texture.

How do you know if pickles are bad?

Foul odors, bubbles in the jar, changes in flavor, color, and brine texture are all indicators that your pickles are rotten, so pay special attention to these changes.


Pickling spice is a must-have in every kitchen, whether it’s for pickles, corned beef, or any other typical food. But, if you can’t locate them for any reason, you now know what you can readily replace in your meals.


What can I use as a substitute for pickling spice?

What may I use instead of pickling spice? Since whole or coarse spices are the distinguishing feature of pickle spice mix, any combination comprising the full, major components may be used as a replacement. This comprises black peppercorns, mustard seeds, red pepper flakes, dill, and other similar ingredients.

What is pickling spice made of?

Pickling spice components may include allspice, bay leaves, cardamom, cinnamon, cloves, coriander, ginger, mustard seeds, and peppercorns (typically whole or in coarse bits). Most stores sell pre-packaged pickling spice blends.

Can you use ground spices for pickling?

Tips for perfecting the recipe:

Utilize only whole seeds: Although most of us have these spices on hand, they are only available in ground form. A pickling mix cannot include ground spices.

What are the ingredients in Mccormick pickling spice?

Ingredients. Cinnamon, Allspice, Mustard Seed, Coriander, Bay Leaves, Ginger, Clove, Red Pepper, Black Pepper, Cardamom, Mace, and Sulfiting Agent are some of the spices used in this recipe.

What is the best pickle substitute?

Green olives may also be used in place of pickle relish. They have a tart and somewhat salty flavor that may complement a variety of tastes. And if you like olives, this may be a two-for-one deal. You may either cut up some green olives and add them to your recipe, or you can make a relish.

What is the difference between mixed spice and pickling spice?

Pickling spice differs from other spice mixes you may be acquainted with (for example, pumpkin pie spice) in that it is prepared using whole, cracked, and ground spices rather than simply ground spices.

What are the 3 basic ingredients in pickling?

Pickling Ingredients to Know
Vinegar. When it comes to choose the finest vinegar for pickling, you have two options: salt or vinegar. There are several salts to choose from when pickling food…. Water. Water is the last of the three major components required to effectively pickle foods. … More Ingredients.

What gives pickles their sour flavor?

The pickle’s salty, sour flavor comes from the acetic acid in vinegar or the lactic acid created by brine. Brine may also incorporate a variety of spices to flavor pickles. Garlic, horseradish, dill, and white mustard seeds are common spices used in brine.

What is Mccormick pickling spice used for?

It’s ideal for seasoning pickles and corned beef, but it may also be used in pot roasts, spiced fruits, and sauerbraten.

What powder keeps pickles crunchy?

Pickling may benefit from the use of calcium chloride as a general firming agent. Many people like it and swear by the results; yet, others argue that nothing can ever surpass the sharpness of a freshly limed pickle.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *