Site Overlay

Mayo Substitute for Tuna

5/5 - (1 vote)

Mayonnaise is a thick and creamy sauce that is created from egg yolks, vinegar or lemon juice, oils, and seasonings. Mayonnaise may be used on a variety of foods. The mixture is whisked quickly while the oil is gradually added until the beautiful sauce that may be used for a variety of purposes is formed. The color of the combination might range from creamy to white to a very light yellow. The flavor is determined by the method of manufacturing; nonetheless, mayonnaise is often sweet and has a hint of sourness from the vinegar or lemon juice that is added. Vitamin E, vitamin K, and carbohydrates are the primary nutrients that may be found in mayonnaise. The health advantages vary from moisturizing the hair and nails to promoting good skin and a healthy immune system. Mayonnaise is so common that almost anyone hasn’t tried it or at least heard of it. Mayonnaise was first created in the year 1756 by a French chef by the name of Duc de Richelieu. This is a fun fact.

Tuna is an excellent choice for either lunch or an afternoon snack since it is loaded with protein as well as omega-3 fatty acids. However, if you slather your tuna sandwich with mayonnaise, you are not making a healthy choice. Mayonnaise has more than 90 calories and 10 grams of fat in only one tablespoon. To combat the dryness without sacrificing either taste or nutrition, try using a mayonnaise alternative that is healthier.

Other Recipes That Call For Mayo

Chicken and Broccoli Casserole with Mayo

Chicken Salad with Grapes, Strawberries, and Apples

Healthy Crustless Broccoli and Ham Quiche

Tuna Rotini Pasta Salad

Posh Squash (Zucchini and Yellow Squash Casserole)

Mayo Substitute for Tuna

Mayonnaise lends a tuna sandwich a level of decadence that is difficult to match. However, considering that the calorie count of mayonnaise is just a few points lower than that of butter, with around 188 calories for two tablespoons of mayonnaise compared to 204 calories for butter, it makes sense to explore for alternatives. You will be relieved to know that there is a plethora of creamy, tasty, and lower-calorie options that you may combine with mayonnaise in order to cut down on the mayonnaise’s high calorie count. If you make a few adjustments, you may still enjoy a delicious tuna sandwich that is fewer in calories.


If you are trying to eat healthier yet like the flavor of avocados, you may use the creamy green fruit in place of mayonnaise. Avocados are a healthier option. In spite of the fact that they do not have the inherently sour taste of mayonnaise, they have a more delicate flavor that works well with a wide range of components. Just 180 calories, more than 7 grams of fiber, and more than 13 grams of beneficial unsaturated fats are included in a half-cup serving of pureed avocado. These nutrients help protect against heart disease. Not only do these kinds of fats bring down levels of the dangerous LDL cholesterol, but they also bring up levels of the beneficial HDL cholesterol. In addition, avocados are an excellent source of the minerals calcium, potassium, and magnesium, as well as the vitamins A and K.

Cottage Cheese

It is possible that cottage cheese, when consumed directly from the container, would seem to be an unsatisfactory replacement for mayonnaise due to its thick and creamy consistency. You may, however, transform the crumbly cheese into a smooth sauce by following a few simple procedures. Place the cottage cheese in a basin, cover it with cheesecloth, and allow it to drain in the refrigerator overnight. Simply use an electric mixer to blitz the remaining curds until they are completely smooth in the morning. Cottage cheese with a low amount of fat is nutritionally comparable to yogurt. One tablespoon of cottage cheese with a low amount of fat has only 10 calories and less than 0.2 grams of fat. However, since it has a lot saltier flavor, you will probably only need to use a fraction of the original amount to get the same level of satisfaction.


This alternative is light and airy, yet it has the consistency of mayonnaise. You may substitute mayonnaise for hummus on sandwiches, just as you can do with avocados. There is no risk that this chickpea-based dip will turn brown on you, and there is also no need to wait for it to mature. You’ll cut 65 calories, 8.5 grams of fat, and 25 milligrams of salt from each tablespoon. An additional gram of protein and fiber is included as a bonus. Make a tuna salad in the manner of the Mediterranean by using hummus for mayonnaise in the recipe. The flavor of all those delicious olives and capers will be brought out to their full potential by the hummus.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is mayonnaise a superfood?

It is reasonable to make this assertion. Mayonnaise is an excellent source of omega-3 fatty acids, and each individual ingredient in the condiment contributes additional health advantages to the whole product. The base of olive oil is beneficial to digestion, the juice of limes or lemons provides vitamin C, and the eggs provide protein, all of which contribute to the building of healthy muscles and tissues. Therefore, it is accurate to say that mayonnaise is a superfood.

Is mayonnaise bad for the brain?

That’s correct. Consuming foods high in saturated fats may cause inflammation throughout the body as well as a buildup of fatty deposits in the arteries. Because of this obstruction, the blood flow to the brain cells may become inadequate or perhaps cease altogether; as a consequence, the brain suffers significant damage.

Can I use butter instead of mayo for tuna?

Because mayonnaise does not provide the same taste that butter does, you are free to use butter instead of mayonnaise on your tuna melt if you so want. Simply keep a careful eye on it and adjust the temperature as necessary to prevent it from catching fire.

Is there a healthy mayo?

Alternatives that are considered to be “healthier” include mayonnaise made with canola oil, avocado oil, and olive oil. The calories are same, despite the fact that both options are richer in the heart-healthy monounsaturated fat. In addition, variants that are based on olive oil often blend olive oil with other vegetable oils so that the taste isn’t too dominant.

Can you eat tuna with butter?

In the event that the tuna steaks have not been marinated, brush them with melted butter or olive oil, and then season them anyway you choose.

Does Greek yogurt taste like mayo?

In almost all cases, Greek Yogurt may serve as a delicious and nutritious alternative to mayonnaise. Both Greek yogurt and mayonnaise have very comparable textures and consistencies, and their tastes are also quite comparable, with the exception that Greek yogurt has a very little hint of tartness to it.

Is mayonnaise good for diabetes?

That’s correct. This condiment is strongly discouraged since it contains an excessive amount of fat; however, if you buy a nice mayonnaise that is produced with olive oil (instead of standard oil), and you keep to just one serving or fewer per day, mayo may be an option that is suitable for people with diabetes. The key to preventing unnecessary waste and excessive consumption is to always measure before distributing.

Mayonnaise is a condiment that is used in a wide variety of dishes, ranging from burgers and cakes to casseroles and casserole dishes. Consider the items on this list as potential replacements in the event that you are out of the original, are trying to reduce the number of calories you consume, dislike the flavor, or adhere to a vegan diet. They are among the very finest alternatives now available.