Site Overlay

Hatch Chile Substitute

5/5 - (1 vote)

The Hatch chile, also known as New Mexican pepper, receives its name from the state in which it is traditionally grown and harvested, New Mexico. In spite of the fact that they are rather common in Mexico, most people in the United States now utilize them. Although the heat level of these peppers may vary widely depending on the type, a common range is anywhere between 1000 and 8000 Scovilles.

They provide a tasty compromise between sweet and spicy flavors. You will appreciate utilizing hatch peppers to create stuffed chiles or roast chile, and they can be found in a variety of sauces, soups, and stews. If you are unable to locate any, go through the list of replacements we provide for hatch chile to choose the one that best fits your needs.

These peppers are not picked until August or September of each year. The flavor is somewhat earthy, which is likely due to the rich soil in which these peppers are cultivated. When eaten raw, the Hatch chile has a flavor similar to that of a fiery pepper with a crisp consistency. On the other hand, roasting them gives them a flavor that is reminiscent of butter and smoked meat.

The taste of both the red and green chilies is robust and tasty to a similar degree. For the purpose of making red chile sauce, both the red and green hatch chilies are dried and crushed into a powder. It is common practice to neglect the adaptability of these peppers, but the sauces made from them may also be used to top apple pies and hamburgers.

Let’s Look at Some of the Top Substitutes for Hatch Chile

1. Anaheim Pepper

Anaheim is a spice that is popular in both Mexican and American cooking; in fact, the city that made it famous gave it its name. It only registers between 500 and 2500 Scoville units of heat. In the United States, this pepper is known for its adaptability and widespread consumption. It is available in a number of different colors, the most common of which is green; nevertheless, ristras are constructed using the red variants.

It’s likely that you’ve heard of chile relleno if you’re familiar with anything at all regarding peppers. Peppers from Anaheim are used in the preparation of this time-honored meal. Any recipe may benefit from the addition of this pepper since it can be purchased already prepared in a can. Because of their intensity, flavor, and adaptability, Anaheim chiles provide a great alternative to hatch chiles in a variety of applications.

2. Cubanelle Pepper

The Scoville rating for this pepper is 1,000, which indicates that it has a medium level of heat. It has a crisp texture and a flavor that is sweet and tangy at the same time. Due to the fact that the walls of this pepper are so paper-thin, it works well whether stuffed, baked, or grilled. They are chosen while they are still unripe and have a green color. They make a simple dinner when pan-fried in olive oil after being harvested in this state.

They are a useful addition to a variety of dishes, including salads, sauces, pizza, and casseroles. Because of their subtle flavor, they are suitable for use in a wide variety of culinary applications. As a consequence of this, we are in a position to assert that it is an outstanding alternative to hatch chiles.

3. Poblano Pepper

In terms of heat, they likewise fall between between 1000 and 2000 Scoville units. After the cooking process is complete, the optimum time to peel and seed a poblano pepper is just before using it. Green poblanos are less hot than matured poblanos.

4. Serrano Pepper

The Serrano pepper has a meaty texture, vibrant flavor, and a moderate amount of spice. Roasting serrano peppers, similar to roasting hatch chiles, will impart a flavor that is smokey and earthy. They are versatile enough to be utilized in the preparation of sauces, salsa, and salad dressings. In contrast to hatch chiles, these peppers with their origin in Mexico cannot be dried.

There is a wide range of color options available for serrano, including yellow, orange, red, and brown. It has a more fiery flavor than a traditional jalapeño. As a consequence of this, serrano may be used as a replacement for hot hatch chile in meals that call for it.

5. Scotch Bonnet

These fiery peppers are most often utilized in the cuisine of the Caribbean. In addition to its intense heat, the scotch bonnet pepper has a taste that is fruity and somewhat sweet. It has a Scoville heat rating of 80,000-400,000 and may be eaten whole, chopped, or sliced in a variety of cuisines due to its medium to high level of heat. It is the most important component of the Caribbean pepper sauce that is so widely known. It may be chopped up and added to a meal while it is being cooked, or it can be used as a seasoning for meat and fish to impart a robust flavor.

The colors vary from yellow to scarlet and even brown when they are fully matured. Even though hatch chiles have a tremendous heat spectrum, they are interchangeable with other hot peppers if you are looking for one.

6. Thai Chiles

Bird’s eye chillies are another name for Thai chilies; they are little, long, and tapering spicy peppers. They do not have a thick shell like other chilies, and their thin, meaty texture is densely packed with small seeds that provide a fiery, fruity flavor to a variety of meals. You can find ancho chiles in the produce section of most grocery stores. They are spicier than Serrano chilies, but not quite as fiery as Ghost or Scorpion chiles. They have a Scoville heat rating of 100,000, and it is recommended that you use them within two weeks after purchase.

If you want a more moderate level of spice, Thai chiles are a great alternative to consider using. Both guntur chilli peppers and Thai chiles provide heat without overpowering the other flavors in a dish. guntur chilli peppers are much more spicy than Thai chiles. Cayenne peppers are a common and widely used spice in dishes that are prepared in Mexican restaurants. They have the look of a brilliant red pepper that is medium in heat and have a flavor that is not very strong. Use Serrano pepper as a replacement for hatch chile due to the fact that bird’s eye chillies may have a very high heat level.

7. Red Chillies

You may use red hatch chillies as a replacement for the hot peppers if you don’t enjoy the heat. This pepper has a high amount of heat and may be found in many different places. It is regarded to be the most similar replacement for spicy pepper there is. You may get it in a number of different forms, including canned, jarred, and whole dried, and some places even offer it fresh. In addition, chili powder made from Hatch peppers may be purchased in the state of California.

Green bell peppers have a flavor that is somewhat sweet, a crisp texture, and a little level of heat. They are a fantastic replacement for hatch chillies due to the fact that they are not as hot. In spite of the fact that they have a lower heat level, they are fantastic for stuffing, baking, grilling, and frying in olive oil. Due to the fact that they have a flavor that is not overpowering, they are versatile enough to be used in a wide range of recipes, including salads, sauces, and casseroles.

Hatch Chile Pepper Cooking Instructions

It is without a doubt an art form to prepare food using Hatch peppers, and one of the questions that is asked the most often in the New Mexico area is “Red or Green?” This question refers to the color of the sauce that you choose to use.

I can speak to the fact that both forms of the pureed red chilli sauce and the pureed green chilli sauce that the locals use to prepare and consume their Hatch peppers are quite tasty in their own right.

What are Some Good Recipes for Hatch Chile?

Here we’ve listed several; have a look!

Hatch Chile and Corn Fritters

These Corn Fritters, also known as corn cakes, are cooked with hatch chiles and include an unexpected ingredient — old bay seasoning – which contributes to their crispiness, sweetness, and a hint of spice. This recipe for corn fritters is perfect for serving as either an appetizer or a side dish, and you’ll want to prepare it again throughout the course of the summer.

Amazing Chicken Tortilla Soup Recipe with Hatch Chiles

The chicken broth used in this recipe for Chicken Tortilla Soup is sure to go down in history as the most delectable you’ve ever tasted. To extract the maximum flavor from the tomatoes, puree them with the onions and garlic first, then add the tomatoes. You may also serve it with a dollop of sour cream on top.

Creamy Roasted Hatch Chile Dip

This Creamy Roasted Hatch Chile Dip is refreshing and creamy, with a bit of fire from roasted hatch chiles and the fresh flavors of lime juice and cilantro. Put all of the ingredients in a blender, give it a good whirl, and then serve.

One-Pot Chili Con Queso Mac and Cheese

Macaroni and cheese with chili con queso, prepared in a single pot and ready in thirty minutes. This macaroni is packed with flavor and can be cooked in the same pot as the rest of the ingredients, which is convenient.

Roasted Hatch Chile Seared Scallops

The Roasted Hatch Chile Seared Scallops are bursting with flavors that are fresh and in season. The sweetness of the scallops provides an excellent counterpoint to the spiciness of the peppers. And it really is a beautiful dish!

Grilled Veggie Burrito Bowls with Hatch Green Chile Rice

These Grilled Veggie Burrito Bowls with Hatch Green Chile Rice are brimming with flavor and make an excellent choice for a healthy lunch due to the fact that each serving has just 500 calories and is laden with the wonderfully vibrant deliciousness of plant-based ingredients.

In addition, here are some other dishes that will keep you busy using Hatch chiles from dawn till night:


  • Make fresh biscuits, then top with Green Chile Country Gravy.
  • Add Hatch chiles to other breeds, such as Rosemary Alu Paratha (Potato Parathas with Fresh Rosemary).
  • Make a spicy breakfast to go with Scrambled Egg Muffins.
  • Make Huevos Rancheros for a hearty start to your day instead (Country-Style Eggs Topped with Pork and Green Chile).


  • Make a better jalapeno pretzel than you would find in a shopping mall.
  • Mix them into the nacho cheese sauce.
  • Isn’t everything better wrapped in bacon? Hatch chiles are no different.
  • Dip salt-crusted potatoes in a Hatch chile-infused cilantro mojo.

Main Courses And Sides

  • Hatch chiles add a spicy kick to soups, stews, and chilli.
  • Try them in savoury pancakes, such as potato pancakes or quinoa cakes.
  • Use them to flavour comfort foods such as potato gratin or macaroni and cheese.
  • Make a fish marinade with Hatch chiles.

How Spicy are Hatch Chile Peppers?

Although most Hatch peppers have a heat level that is around one-third that of a standard jalapeño pepper, some Hatch peppers have a heat level that is comparable to that of a jalapeno. Because there are many different varieties of chili peppers that are categorized as Hatch Chile Peppers, the heat levels of these peppers may vary from approximately 1,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU), which are considered to be very moderate, to over 8,000 SHU. You may get further information on the Scoville Scale by clicking here.

There are several varieties of Hatch peppers, and some of those varieties might have a higher heat level than others. I’ve heard that some of them may have a heat level comparable to that of habanero peppers.

How do Hatch Chile Peppers Taste?

The use of hatch peppers is exploding in popularity not just in New Mexico and the surrounding area, but also throughout the whole of the United States. They have a flavor that is comparable to that of Anaheim chili peppers, which is earthy. Others contend that the soil is immaterial and that the plants taste fine regardless of where they are produced, while others claim that the rich regional soil in which they are cultivated favorably impacts their flavors and contributes to their overall quality.

Raw, they have a flavor that is sharp, peppery, and somewhat pungent, comparable to that of an onion. However, they are often roasted, which gives them a flavor that is smokey, deep, earthier, and occasionally buttery. Raw, they have this flavor.

When compared to fully matured red chiles, the sting of hatch green chiles is somewhat stronger. The heat that is delivered by hatch chiles varies from a sharp bite at the beginning to a more gradual buildup of intensity.

What does Hatch Chiles Use in?

In New Mexico and across the United States, hatch peppers are a common ingredient in a broad range of meals. This is especially true in New Mexico. They are used in the preparation of a wide variety of foods, including soups and stews, sauces, chopped and cooked into chilis, and other common cuisines. In addition, they are often used for stuffing peppers. The roasted chile is quite popular. However, roasted Hatch green chiles bring out the flavors of fresh Hatch peppers in a variety of meals much more than fresh Hatch peppers do on their own. And also the color Red.

Is it Possible to Grow Hatch Chile Peppers?

Certainly! You may start Hatch peppers from seed or purchase seedlings and grow them in your own garden or anyplace else where chili peppers can be produced. Either way, you can eat the peppers. However, due to the fact that they will not be produced in Hatch, New Mexico, it is impossible for them to be labeled “Hatch Chile Peppers.”

When does Hatch Chile Season Begin?

Because of their greater size and thicker wall thickness, Hatch chile peppers have an extremely condensed growth season. They are normally gathered throughout the months of August and September of each year; however, the harvesting season may be prolonged by a few of weeks on each side depending on the weather.

What Stores Sell Hatch Chile Peppers?

Hatch chile peppers were not previously accessible anywhere outside of the area around Hatch, New Mexico; nevertheless, they are now readily available in a variety of grocery shops and online sellers throughout the country. I placed an order for roasted Hatch chile peppers online, and the delivery was made with them in a frozen state.

This method makes them simple to preserve and ensures that they retain their delicious flavor. It’s possible that roasted Hatch chile is more to your liking than fresh chile.

What Makes Hatch Chiles Unique?

The spice and sweetness of hatch chiles are perfectly balanced in one pepper. On the Scoville scale, mild Hatch chiles are best for individuals who are looking for merely the smokey flavor, while very hot Hatch chiles may equal the level of heat produced by the New Mexico sun (we assume).


As a direct consequence of this, there are a great deal of feasible alternatives to hatch chile. You are free to choose any of the preceding selections provided that it is suitable for the food you are preparing. Although Anaheim is often regarded to be the most convenient choice, other locations will do in a pinch.

We really hope that you found this article to be informative, and that after reading it, you have a better understanding of what other ingredients may be used in lieu of hatch chile. Therefore, “Worry Less and Cook More.”