Site Overlay

Frosting substitute for cream cheese

Rate this post

You’re most likely one of those bakers (or cake fans in general) who prefer the frosting over the cake. So you’re picky about what goes into producing it. If so, you’re probably aware that cream cheese is a popular component in frosting recipes. Who wouldn’t enjoy the delightful and distinct tangy richness that cream cheese adds to recipes? But, cream cheese may not always be readily accessible. There may be instances when you want a different flavor or want to avoid the calories and fat that cream cheese provides.

It should thus delight you to know that alternative replacements may be utilized in frosting recipes to approximate the sour richness of cream cheese. It is critical to understand how to apply these alternatives in the precise techniques and proportions to guarantee that your frosting is excellent and delicious. It would also be useful to understand what characteristics make a replacement ideal for substituting cream cheese in frosting recipes.

What is Cream Cheese?

Cream cheese is a fresh cheese prepared from cow milk and cream that has a gentle and creamy taste. Its freshness is indicated by the presence of cow milk in its composition. Cream cheese is identical to other dairy products such as cream, milk, butter, and yogurt. It may be used in both sweet and savory meals.

During the cream cheese manufacturing process, lactic acid bacteria are injected into the cream, causing the pH to decrease and the fat to separate from the liquid, causing it to curdle. The mixture is then boiled, and stabilizers such as carob bean gum and carrageenan are added to make cream cheese.

Cream cheese is often used as a creamy dip for potato chips and other snack items, as well as in salads. Spreads like yogurt and pepper jelly may be made by combining it with additional ingredients. It may also be used in the kitchen to thicken and cream sauces and to create cheesecake.

Cream Cheese Nutrition Facts

Cream Cheese Uses in Frosting Recipes

Cream cheese is a well-known cheese, perhaps due to its mild taste, which enables it to be used in a variety of sweet and savory recipes. It is used to give tangy richness to a variety of dishes.

Cream cheese, in addition to these purposes, is used in frosting recipes. If your frosting is very sugary and runny, try adding some cream cheese. This will assist to thicken the frosting and provide a tart contrast to the sweetness. Cream cheese is often used in the following frosting recipes:

  • Buttercream icing
  • Frosting with ermine
  • Chocolate icing
  • Frosting with vanilla cream cheese
  • Brown butter icing
  • Frosting made with white chocolate pudding
  • Frosting with lemon cream cheese
  • Buttermilk frosting that is fluffy and light.
  • Frosting with coconut buttercream
  • Red velvet icing
  • Frosting with marshmallow buttercream
  • Frosting with chocolate ganache
  • Cream cheese frosting with cinnamon sugar
  • Frosting with cookies and cream
  • Frosting with key lime pie flavor

Substitutes for Cream Cheese in Frosting

Cream cheese is a versatile and popular component in many culinary processes, particularly baking. With its mild taste and tangy richness, it’s no surprise that many people choose to use it in frosting recipes. Yet, it has the benefit of properly thickening frosting and adding a contrasting tanginess in circumstances when icing is too sweet. But, there may come a moment when you want a different flavor in your frosting recipes, or you’ve ran out of cream cheese in your cupboard entirely. Moreover, since cream cheese is largely comprised of milk and cream, it has a high fat and calorie content. You may want to avoid using cream cheese because of health risks. In such cases, there are fantastic alternatives for cream cheese that might function as wonderful replacements. But, in order to get the greatest results, it is essential to learn how to utilize these replacements in lieu of cream cheese.

Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta cheese is an Italian cheese with a smooth texture and a sweet, tangy taste. It has a creamy finish and a milder flavor than other cheeses when eaten fresh. It, like cream cheese and other dairy products, has a high protein, calcium, vitamin B12, and riboflavin content.

Cottage cheese, although not as thick as cream cheese, works nicely as a filling or as an ingredient in sauces and spreads. It may also be used with an equal quantity of heavy cream or yogurt to make baked goods and desserts. Ricotta cheese has a crumbly texture, so if you want to use it as a cream cheese alternative in a cheesecake or cake frosting recipe, mix it with equal parts heavy cream or yogurt for a better taste and texture.

Cottage Cheese

Cottage cheese is a fresh yogurt-based cheese that is not generally aged. This sort of cheese has less fat than ordinary cream cheese. Cottage cheese, which contains 70% protein and 11% of the daily calcium requirement, is a great replacement for cream cheese.

In many respects, cottage cheese and cream cheese are interchangeable. Cottage cheese, on the other hand, has a chunkier texture and is somewhat lower in fat. To make the texture smoother, blend cottage cheese with a splash of lemon juice. Cottage cheese may be used in place of cream cheese in dips and spreads in equal proportions. Before using it in baking or cooking, consider thickening it with cream or half-and-half. To use cottage cheese as a cream cheese alternative in desserts and frostings, add an equivalent quantity of heavy cream.


Mascarpone is a high-fat cream cheese that is often made using cream rather than milk. Mascarpone is maybe the best cream cheese replacement. This soft cheese is richer and creamier than cream cheese, yet it may be used in many of the same recipes as cream cheese. It has a richer, more velvety texture that complements many dishes, particularly fillings, spreads, frostings, and desserts, while being higher in fat and calories than cream cheese. If you want to mimic the tangy flavor of cream cheese in mascarpone, season it with a teaspoon of salt and a spritz of fresh lemon juice. If you have calorie-related health issues, you should examine different substitution choices.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I use milk instead of cream cheese?

Generally, milk isn’t a decent alternative for cream cheese. It has the ability to mimic the taste. But, since milk has a thin consistency, it will not be the same.

What is the difference between cream cheese and Greek yogurt? 

The purpose of cream cheese manufacture is to drain as much whey as possible, resulting in a semi-solid texture. Rennet assists in curdling solids and liquid extraction. The draining procedure is optional for yogurt, however it is recommended if you want a thicker Greek-style yogurt.

Can I use silken tofu instead of cream cheese?

Because of its creamy texture, silken and soft tofu may be readily incorporated into a variety of delicacies. In this scenario, tofu works well as a cream cheese alternative.


If you want to imitate the particular richness of cream cheese in your frosting recipes, you can try one of our recommended substitutes. These possibilities range in origin and composition, but if utilized in the proper proportions and procedures, they will sufficient to perform the traditional duties of cream cheese in various types of frostings. Therefore, the next time you run out of cream cheese, have health concerns, or a yearning for something different, all you have to do is experiment with something new. You may be surprised by what you find.


Is there a substitute for cream cheese in frosting?

Even though it may seem impossible, some of the greatest cream cheese replacements for a frosting recipe include ricotta cheese, cottage cheese, and Greek yogurt, as well as vegan choices like silken tofu and a combination of vegan butter and nondairy milk.

How do you mimic cream cheese flavor?

Chef’s Pencil’s culinary specialists advocate combining ricotta with an equal quantity of full-fat (unsweetened) yogurt as a 1:1 equivalent that better mimics both the texture and taste of cream cheese in savory meals.

What can I use if I don’t have cream cheese?

Sour cream may be used in place of cream cheese. Sour cream tastes similar to cream cheese but is lower in calories, making it an excellent low-calorie option.
… Greek Yogurt…. Mascarpone…. Silken Tofu…. Cottage Cheese…. Hummus…. Quark.
Additional details…•February 1, 2022

Can I use milk instead of cream cheese?

4 cups cream should suffice. Substitutions: Half and Half and Heavy Cream – You may also use full whole milk, but the result will be more ricotta than cream cheese. Heavy cream – You may also use half and half or any other combination of half and half and cream. The total amount of milk

How do you thicken frosting without cream cheese?

Mix together the powdered sugar

If your frosting hasn’t thickened enough after cooling, add a few tablespoons of sifted powdered sugar to help your buttercream stiffen.

Why add cream cheese to frosting?

Mix in the cream cheese

When you add softened cream cheese to store-bought icing, it becomes 100 times better! It provides richness to the frosting while regulating its sweetness. Combine one container of room temperature frosting with one 8oz box of room temperature cream cheese to make a nice, simple frosting.

Can Mayo be used in place of cream cheese?

Can I substitute mayonnaise for cream cheese? You certainly can. Mayo has a creamy texture, spreadability, and a sweet taste similar to cream cheese. This will be determined by the taste character you choose as well as the consistency required for the recipe.

Is there a non dairy substitute for cream cheese?

Silken tofu puree has the texture of cream cheese and may be used in both sweet and savory meals. Cashew or almond cream cheeses: These vegan alternatives are created from cashews or almonds. They are both flexible, however almond cream cheese works best in sweet recipes and cashew butter in savory meals.

Can I use heavy whipping cream instead of cream cheese?

Cream cheese may be used in place of heavy cream at a 1:1 ratio. Keep in mind that cream cheese may change the taste and texture of the final product, so use it in recipes where the tastes will complement one other, such as creamy soups or cheesy sauces.

Can I use cream cheese and milk instead of cream?

With cream cheese and milk

It may also be used in soups, sauces, and chowders if diluted with water or milk. Adding milk to cream cheese will make it creamier and looser, so keep this in mind when adding any liquid to your heavy cream substitute.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *