Site Overlay

Cornstarch substitute in pie

Rate this post

Pies are made of pastry flour and filled with a variety of sweet or savory ingredients. Corn starch is a thickening that is used in pie fillings to prevent them from becoming mushy. If you use too many thickeners or not enough, your pie will be too watery or rubbery. To produce tasty pies, thickeners must be used in the filling.

Likewise, the quantity of thickener you’ll need is determined by how much sugar you’ll be using in your recipes. During baking, sugar, for example, may hold a lot of moisture, making your pie watery and leaving you with a messy feast.

Cornflour, often known as cornstarch, may not be widely accessible. As a result, you must find an alternative to compensate. Thickeners come in a variety of forms. You may use any of these in place of corn starch, depending on their qualities or the type of your pie. This page looks at all of the thickeners that may be used in place of cornstarch.

What is Cornstarch? 

This is created from corn starch. It’s simple to see where the name came from. Simply described, corn-starch is a form of starch powder derived from corn kernels. To extract the starch from the maize, all of the outer bran and germ are removed, leaving just the rich endosperm.

Cornflour is a term often used in Europe to refer to cornstarch. Corn-starch thickens pies when heated at high temperatures; this occurs when the starch granules absorb water and expand like a balloon, filling the pie and thickening it like a sauce. As a result, cornstarch needs a high temperature to thicken pies.

It’s crucial to remember that overheating or whisking the cornflour after it’s thickened might cause it to lose its thickening capacity. If you use too much cornstarch if your pie is undercooked, it may leave a chalky taste in your dish. The use of cornflour gives your filling a velvety texture.

Cornstarch Nutrition Facts

Uses of Cornstarch in Recipes

Corn starch is used as a thickening in a wide variety of dishes. Soups, stews, and, most notably, pie fillings. Since cornflour is denser than flour, a thickening, it may thicken liquids quicker and with more consistency, making it a popular thickener.

Using cornstarch and flour together makes your dessert chewy and light. It may also be of interest to you that cornflour has been used in applications other than thickening, such as an anti-caking agent in finely powdered commodities to prevent lumping.

Cornflour is used in a number of pie recipes. Here are a few examples:

  • Blueberry pie perfection
  • Pie with coconut cream
  • Pie with peaches
  • Pie with mixed berries
  • Traditional pumpkin pie
  • Pie crust with melted butter
  • Rhubarb pie from scratch
  • Pie with vanilla cream
  • Pie with sugar and cream
  • Pie with butterscotch filling
  • Pie with apples
  • Lemon meringue tart
  • Pie with pecans
  • Pie with strawberries
  • Pie with chocolate chess on top.

Substitute for Cornstarch in Recipes

Understanding the importance of cornstarch in providing the correct texture for our pies. When we run out of cornstarch, we have the option of seeking for a replacement or making a running pie. The latter is a total mess, therefore we’ll look into some alternatives right now.

All-Purpose Flour

It contains 75% starch, which is responsible for the thickening of pies, as previously described. Low gluten soft wheat and high gluten hard wheat are used to make All-Purpose Flour.

It does not need a high temperature to thicken the liquid to which it is added, unlike cornstarch. It can also resist high temperatures without losing its thickening ability. To substitute corn flour, use about one-half the amount of flour specified in the recipe, since all-purpose flour takes greater quantity to thicken. Sometimes, your pie may turn gummy or have a wheat flour flavor.


Maybe you’re seeking for a thickening that won’t interfere with the taste of your pie. Then you’re seeking for tapioca that cooks quickly. It is sold as a finely crushed powder and is manufactured from cassava plant roots that have been pregelatinized.

When hydrated, it takes on a brilliant, smooth, and sometimes gluey texture. It releases starch at lower temperatures, which gelatinizes and thickens your filling. When cooked over an extended period of time, it loses its thickening ability.

Potato Starch

This thickener, manufactured by extracting starch from potatoes, is regarded the most potent of all thickeners, thickening at moderate temperatures but losing its thickening capacity when heated for an extended period of time. When utilizing cornflour, higher quantities are often necessary than when using flour. It may add flavor to your pie, but it is typically subtle and manageable.

Frequently asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I bake with Corn-starch instead of Flour?

Although flour may be used as a thickening agent, cornflour cannot be utilized to replace flour in baked products. Nevertheless, using cornstarch instead of flour to fry dishes is OK since it absorbs less frying oil than flour.

Why is Corn-starch bad for you? 

Corn starch has few vital elements since it is mostly composed of carbohydrates and is heavy in calories. It may induce a rise in blood pressure and, ultimately, inflammatory reactions, leading your health to decline.

How much Corn-starch can I put in a pie?

It depends on the kind of Pie. Pies made with luscious fruits usually need fewer thickeners: one teaspoon to one tablespoon of cornstarch for every 8 cups of fruit in a 9-inch pie. But, always consult your recipe book for accurate pie measurements.


For whatever reason you decide to replace cornstarch in your meals, it is crucial to understand that there is typically a noticeable difference when using different thickeners in a pie, which may result in a change in flavor or texture.

It should be noted that all Corn-starch replacements are temperature sensitive and may need varied amounts to obtain the desired outcomes. After that, you’re good to go; there’s no need for a watery pie when you can discover superior replacements for your delectable pies just as fast.


What can I use in place of cornstarch in a pie?

6 Cornstarch Substitutes for Everyday Cooking and Baking
Starch from potatoes. Kendra Vaculin, assistant food editor, prefers potato starch as a cornstarch replacement. . Rice Flour. All-Purpose Flour. Tapioca Flour. Arrowroot Powder. Xanthan Gum.
Jun 13, 2022

What is a substitution for cornstarch?

Most chefs advocate using 2 tablespoons tapioca flour for 1 tablespoon cornstarch. Tapioca is a starch flour derived from the root vegetable cassava. For each tablespoon of cornstarch, use about 2 teaspoons tapioca flour.

Can I use plain flour instead of cornstarch?

While it will not provide the same glossy sheen as cornstarch, it will suffice in a hurry. All-purpose flour has about half the thickening ability of cornstarch, so for every tablespoon of cornstarch needed, use two teaspoons of all-purpose flour.

How do I substitute cornstarch for flour in pies?

All-purpose flour is a simple alternative for cornstarch; in fact, either may be used to thicken pie fillings or soups. In a recipe, 2 tablespoons of flour are required for every 1 tablespoon of cornstarch.

How can I thicken a pie filling without cornstarch?

All-purpose flour is a simple option since you almost certainly have it in your cupboard. Since it has less starch, you’ll need more of it than with higher-starch thickeners. Tapioca, which cooks quickly, adds a stippled and somewhat sticky texture to the filling.

What is the best thickener for pie filling?

Cornstarch creates a gleaming, glossy filling. Since it has double the gelling strength of flour, a little goes a long way. Flour thickens beautifully but has a matte appearance. You’ll need twice as much as you would for cornstarch.

Can you skip cornstarch in a recipe?

Cornstarch is used in a number of dishes to thicken liquids, including sauces, gravies, pies, puddings, and stir-fries. Flour, arrowroot, potato starch, tapioca, and even instant mashed potato granules may be used in its stead.

What does cornstarch do in baking?

Cornstarch adds a crumbly and delicate dessert-like texture to cake, cookie, pie filling, and shortbread recipes. Cornstarch is often used as an anti-caking agent in the food industry.

What can I substitute with in the absence of 1 tablespoon of cornstarch in ingredients?

1 tablespoon cornstarch (for thickening).

2 tablespoons all-purpose flour or 2 teaspoons granular tapioca may be substituted.

How much flour is equal to 1 4 cup of cornstarch?

It’s worth noting that cornstarch thickens twice as well as flour. If you need to replace cornstarch for 14 cup (four tablespoons) flour in a gravy recipe, use just two tablespoons cornstarch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *