Site Overlay

Broiler Pan Substitutes

Rate this post

Many people prefer broiling to other ways of preparing food, and for good reason. Broiling enables for healthier cooking methods since it utilizes direct heat and eliminates the usage of fat and oil. This is beneficial since it lowers the chance of developing cholesterol-related disorders.

Broiling adds a lot of flavor to dishes since it primarily cooks their fat. Additionally, it imparts a caramelized taste to dishes prepared using other cooking methods.

Broiler pans are vital kitchenware that should not be overlooked while broiling. They are ideal for both indoor and outdoor cooking and are a terrific complement to any kitchen’s essential items. Nevertheless, they may not always be readily accessible for usage, necessitating the employment of alternate knives in their stead. It is also critical to learn how to utilize these broiler pan replacements correctly in order to get the ideal cooking outcomes.

What is a Broiler Pan?

A broiler pan, also known as a broiler roaster, oven roaster, or oven broiling pan, is a kind of cookware. It is used in the oven to broil foods such as steaks, roasts, or many sorts of meat, poultry, and vegetables. They are often constructed of stainless steel or heavy-gauge steel with black porcelain enamel.

Broiler pans are made up of two parts: a low-walled pan and a higher cooking surface that serves as the boilerplate’s lid. The cooking surface or cover keeps the broiling food in place. The drippings from the food being cooked are captured in the pan below by the open slots and tiny holes in this cover. The tiny perforations in the lid keep heated fat and drippings contained inside the pan, keeping them from igniting and scorching the bottom of the meal while it broils.

With a cooking surface ranging from 6 to 12 inches broad and 10 to 18 inches long, a broiler pan may be sized to accommodate a range of ovens and culinary activities.

Broiler Pan Uses in Recipes

Broiling is a cooking technique that uses dry, direct heat to cook solid food. Broiling the food is usually done directly on the heat source. Broiling adds a lot of flavor to foods since it mostly cooks the fat. Broiling may also be used to caramelize food that has already been cooked in another method.

Broiler pans, as the name indicates, are crucial in the broiling process of various delectable dishes. Broiler pans are often used in the following recipes:

  • a tender steak
  • Dilly beans with salmon
  • Lemon pepper tilapia broiled
  • Sandwiches with beef and roasted red peppers
  • Breaded shrimp with Harissa and beer
  • Sandwiches with Portobello mushrooms
  • Lentils with grilled eggplant
  • Simple broiled chicken breast
  • California’s melting
  • Teriyaki chicken thighs broiled
  • Nachos Superstars
  • Sardines with Gremolata, broiled
  • Gratin of Broccoli and Cauliflower
  • Grapefruit, broiled
  • Sweet potatoes roasted

Substitutes for Broiler Pan

A broiler pan in your kitchen allows you to prepare nutritious dishes that promote a healthy lifestyle. Since it cooks your food to perfection with little or no oil, it is a low-calorie cooking technique.

Unfortunately, there may come a moment when you need a broiler pan but do not have one on hand. But, there is no need for concern! There are various substitution choices that you may use in its place to attain the desired outcomes in your recipes. Several of these alternatives are detailed below:

Cast-iron Griddle Pans

Cast-iron pans are normally made from a single piece of cast iron. They are versatile, long-lasting, and contribute to great meals. This is due mostly to the material used, cast iron, which is a good heat conductor capable of withstanding very high temperatures.

Some of these pans are enameled and nonstick, while others are not and must be cleaned on a regular basis. Since these pans can resist high temperatures, they will not be harmed if put near broiling food. Moreover, the extended handle and grab grip components of griddle pans make moving them much easier.

When searching for cast-iron pans for broiling, look for ones with griddle lines, which may be used in lieu of a broiler cover or wire rack. Its lines should also be high enough to prevent the food item from being submerged in its fluids.

Baking Sheets

A baking sheet, also known as a baking tray or sheet pan, is a rectangular metal pan that is often constructed of aluminum or stainless steel. It is widely used in the baking of bread rolls, pastries, pizzas, and other similar items. In terms of design, these aren’t even close to broiling trays, but they’ll do in a hurry.

Baking sheets are made of the same materials as broiling and roasting pans, enabling them to withstand high temperatures. Place the food item on top of an aluminum foil-lined baking sheet (for easy cleaning). Put the tray as near to the broiling burner as possible and continue cooking as normal.

It is crucial to limit the quantity of moisture in the diet by eliminating marinades and sauces. Likewise, keep a close check on the food in case the fluids catch fire.

Roasting Trays with Wire Racks

Roasting trays are fantastic and, in my opinion, the finest alternative to broiling pans. During roasting, these trays are meant to aid with air circulation around the meal. These perform similarly to genuine broiling pans when placed near broiling food.

The primary difficulty you may have is that the fluids from the broiling meal might catch fire in the high heat. Keeping an eye on your diet, on the other hand, may help you prevent this.

It is important to note that roasting trays should not be used in isolation. These should be used in conjunction with a wire rack to create a makeshift broiling pan. The wire rack will help juice drain into the drip tray. Roasting pans with pre-installed wire racks are also available.

Aluminum Foil Trays

Aluminum trays are affordable and available in a variety of sizes and forms, making it easy to pick one that meets your needs. When purchasing an aluminum foil tray, look for ones that are labeled heavy-duty, although not all are. They are a last choice, but they allow for rapid and simple cleaning, saving you a significant amount of time and effort. Aluminum foil trays can also withstand the high temperatures required by the broiling process.

The item to be broiled comes into direct contact with the tray, exactly as it does with baking sheets. Thankfully, no lubricant is necessary since it interacts with the food in the same way as aluminum foil does. To stay on the safe side and for extra taste and color, brush the food with oil.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What pans are safe for broiling?

All-metal pans, such as stainless steel or seasoned cast iron, are your safest choice unless your nonstick cookware or bakeware says it is broiler-safe or safe up to 550F.

Can you broil something in a glass pan?

Putting a glass under a broiler, even if it is solid and reinforced, is not suggested. Use a heat-resistant metal pan or rimmed sheet pan instead.

Is broiling the same as baking?

Broiling is distinct from baking in that the food is surrounded by hot air and hence cooks more slowly. Some chefs recommend a two-step procedure of baking followed by broiling to keep a protein-like chicken moist.


Adding the broiling method into your dishes is an excellent way to add a variety of tastes and savour to your meals. Because of the way it avoids fat, it is also a particularly healthy cooking alternative. Do we endorse it? Absolutely, without a doubt!

While broiling food, a broiler pan is an excellent piece of cookware to use. Yet, if you do not have access to one, you may always improvise. Try one or more of our broiler pan alternatives, and you’ll be pleasantly surprised at how well they perform!


Can I use a regular pan for broiling?

When using a broiler, use sturdy metal pans or a basic rimmed sheet pan. If you use anything different (such as a glass pan), the heat from the broiler may cause it to fracture or shatter. Our favorite sheet pan from the Test Kitchen is usually a safe bet.

Is a broiler pan necessary?

Cooking dishes on a grated broiler pan is not necessarily essential. This pan enables air to flow underneath the meal, although the same effect may be achieved simply turning the dish halfway through cooking.

Can aluminum foil go under broiler?

If you don’t have a nonstick pan or are preparing a messy dish, line the top and bottom of the broiler pan with conventional or nonstick aluminum foil. Make slits in the foil on the top of the broiler pan to allow fat to drain.

Can I use a cookie sheet to broil?

The nonstick coating on your pan or baking sheet is not intended to withstand high broiler temperatures (or direct flame).

Can I broil in a Pyrex dish?

Toll-free number for Revere is 800-999-3436. PyrexOven-safe glass baking dishes, such as Pyrex, should not be used for broiling. The majority of them are not suitable for use on the stove. Call Corning for more information on using glass cookware.

Can you use parchment paper on a broiler pan?

Although parchment paper is resistant to heat, it is not heat proof. It may catch fire if it comes too near to a top-down broiler. Line your broiler tray with foil if possible.

What can I use instead of a broiler pan for meatloaf?

Use a sheet pan or a big baking dish instead, and give enough breathing area for the edges to brown gently.

Can you put nonstick pan in broiler?

*Chemours does not advocate using TeflonTM nonstick coated cookware for broiling or cooking at broiling temperatures.

Can you put a nonstick pan under the broiler?

Most nonstick pans, regardless of composition, suggest heating to a maximum of 350°F or 500°F. Never use a nonstick pan on the broiler setting, no matter what kind it is.

Do I leave oven door open when broiling?

It is customary to keep the oven door slightly ajar. This permits heat to escape and requires the broil element to remain on instead of cycling on and off. For broiling for brief periods of time, such as when cooking thinner meats, top browning, or searing meat, open door broiling is ideal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *